From Eoghann Irving · 1996-04-12 02:09 · #77468 in TREK.UK
In reply to Women? by Aaron Carr
It was 09 Apr 96 when Aaron Carr turned to me and uttered these fatefull words:
AC> Many rpgs concentrate on action... this includes most that are based on
AC> films (or at least that sort of cinematic style), including (those that
AC> come to mind straight away): Star Wars, AD&D, Judge Dredd (I know this
AC> was _way_ before the film, but its still very action orientated, cos of
AC> the comics). Many others however are different, Vampire (etc, etc) for
AC> instance. I think the main point as to determining whether rpg _are_
AC> about fighting and conquering is the person (nearly said 'bloke' then)
AC> ;) that's running the game, they can make it however they want to..
True, the GM is the single most important person when it comes to setting the style and tone of the game. But a little bit of encouragement wouldn't do any harm. A greater variety would be nice too. Most RPGs are simply variations on a theme. A fun theme in most cases, but even so....
I haven't played Vampire, so I won't jump to any conclusions, but I've tried other White Wolf games and they strike me as something of a triumph of style over substance. Lots of great atmosphere, but not mechanics to back it up.
AC> As to whether it matters if women play rpgs, I'm not going to force
AC> people to play, nor should there be specifically 'female' roleplaying
AC> games.. I can't speak for women (well I could, but I wouldn't be very
AC> good at it) ;) but I would find that extreemly patronising. I know of a
AC> few women roleplayers, most of them I've found to be girlfriends of
AC> people who play rpgs. I would like to see more women playing rpgs, and
AC> I don't see any reason why they (that sounds really generalistic -
AC> sorry!) shouldn't enjoy the hobby, saying that 'they' don't play
AC> because it's all about fighting is just stereotyping both women and
AC> rpgs.
I certainly wouldn't want female roleplaying games. Roleplaying games from a female perspective are another matter. Granted the original editorial was somewhat sweeping in its statement, but I think it may be true to some extent at least.
I haven't actually had a women reply to this topic yet. Are there any out there? It would be rather handy to have a woman's viewpoint on this I think. :)
Have Fun,
Eoghann
************************************************************
*** New SUPER SIZZLE. It's SO good we ate the baby! ***
************************************************************
--- Spot 1.3a Unregistered
* Origin: A deeply distrubed mind (2:440/302.14@FidoNet)