From Ian Muirhead · 1996-04-09 17:19 · #77444 in TREK.UK
In reply to Come on people....! by Graham Marsden
Well Met Graham! 06 Apr 96 18:13, Graham Marsden spoketh to Ian Muirhead: About: Come on people....! GM> [Re: Someone has *got* to have *something* interesting to talk GM> about!!] GM> Wow! One message and we get no less than *three* meaty topics to get GM> our teeth into...! ;-) Indeed, and it's got everybody out of the woodwork, I rever realised there were this many people in here :) IM>> what do people think about the current state of the RPG industry, IM>> given that the CCG's seem to be taking over, already we have seen IM>> a couple of publishers gone bust, and before long I bet many of IM>> the CCG publishers will go the same way, I personally feel they IM>> are killing the rpg industry, what does anybody else think... GM> I assume by CCGs you mean Collectable Card Games eg Magic otherwise GM> the rest of this message is going to be a bit redundant! Yep... GM> I think the problem with conventional RPGs is that they require too GM> much organisation and coordination. You have to get a group of people GM> together, in the same place at the same time (hoping that no one is GM> too busy or doesn't feel like playing), get someone to work out a GM> scenario and run the game and then play for several hours. If you can't sort it out, join a club, I did, and from that, I'm now going around other members houses to run/play games out of club hours... and it's not that difficult to sort out, set a date and time, a free afternoon for example, and you're away... GM> CCGs on the other hand require a *lot* less planning and GM> organisation. GM> If you meet with a friend and they say "fancy a game of Magic?", you GM> just take out your decks and *go*. You only need two people, you play GM> for as long as it suits you and you stop when you feel like it. It's not the same as a rpg however, theres no character interaction you basically choose the best card and place it on the table, it's not exactly what I'd call engrosssing... another thing, it's all very well, just starting a game, but most of the people who play this type of game that I know have briefcases full of them, each deck carefully tuned, if the only way to get a decent set is to buy about 1000 worth of decks, it's a licence to print money... GM> I think that CCGs are going to cause (indeed, have caused) the RPG GM> industry to take a *long* hard look at itself and see just where it is GM> going. Several RPG companies jumped on the CCG band wagon, but I think GM> several of them fell of in a spectacular manner too! T$R is doggedly staying on with its spellfire series, even though from what I hear nobody plays it... GM> Although CCGs are going to have a limited life span, they are going GM> to change the face of RPGs forever. GM> I predict that future games will rely a lot more on the roleplaying GM> aspect and a lot less on the piles of books and masses of dice. They GM> will be simpler to set up and they will be easier to run on an "ad GM> hoc" basis. Quite a few of the games being released this year (ie, T$Rs Dragonlance: Fifth Age rpg) are having the dice replaced with cards GM> I don't think that the RPG industry is going to die, but it is well GM> overdue for a large amount of soul searching. I've got no problem with piles of dice, and I suspect that many other gamers feel the same way... IM> .!. "The eerie, wailing Hymm caused insanity even in hardened IM> warriors." GM> "Come and 'ave a go if you think you're 'ard enough...!" GM> or "You're gonna get your &#$%^*@ 'eads kicked in...!" GM> ;-) hehe :) By Your Leave Graham --> Ian Muirhead <-- ... There's nothing like a dog to give your home that lived-in look. --- * Origin: The Silver Dragons Lair, off the Pleasure Dome BBS (2:2501/10.1)