Slimelite BBS

Problems with Sportster V.34 and TrapDoor 1.85

Back to IBM

From Peter Deane · 1996-03-17 13:11 · #77314 in IBM

 PD> Same thing really...  Modem still returns NO CARRIER.  One is because
 PD> the modem decided to do it (S7 reached) the other is because Terminus
 PD> sent the modem a CR while a DIAL command has been executed.  Same end
 PD> result, though, there.

 MR> Yes, but doesn't TD send a CR when i aborts a call without 
 MR> RINGING's to count? If it did send a CR to abort the call, 
 MR> shouldn't it get a NO CARRIER and at least not terminate.

The timeout in TrapDoor is about 90 seconds.  What's your S7 setting? My bet is greater than 90 seconds????

 MR> Really, how come TD tells me that my Sportster doesn't even 
 MR> sends it a NO CARRIER while Terminus receives NO CARRIER after 
 MR> an unanswered call? I use exactly the same init and dial strings 
 MR> in both serial programmes BTW.

Because in Terminus, there is a delay between the ATDT commands, whereas with the Arexx script, there probably won't be.

 PD> Aha, I just re-read that bit.  No response from modem means the modem
 PD> has done NOTHING after getting the Dial command.  99% of the time this
 PD> is because the command is being sent too fast to the modem, and easily
 PD> solved by changing the MODEMDIALPRE string.

 MR> I think this is the strange part. The modem calls the right 
 MR> number. I have verified this and I'm loath to admit that the 
 MR> Sportster could handle calls to busy numbers and disconnected 
 MR> numbers while, for some reason, it should somehow miss something 
 MR> while calling a non-answering modem?

Yes, it's a quicker modem, and is ready to take the AT commands fired off quickly.  The No Response from Modem problem is one I had years ago, and it has appeared in this echo several times.  It's ALWAYS fixed by adding tildes in before the dial command.  Try it at least once, please!

 PD> You might have to experiment on the number of tilde characters (~) you
 PD> use, but you'll definitely need one or two before the AT, and possibly
 PD> one after the AT and before the D.  The one at the end is just for
 PD> decoration, really :-)

 MR> I could try this but why should the Sportster work when dialling 
 MR> numbers that are busy and disconnected and not work while 
 MR> TrapDoor calls a number that doesn't answer?

I don't think you're diagnosing it properly there.  No Response From Modem almost always means that the ATDT command had no effect on the modem.  IE no text was returned from it (not even a NO CARRIER).  That's because the modem has "eaten" the dial command because it got it too quickly after a previous call out instruction.   Use those tildes in your dial string, you'll see....

  Mea Culpa,
 Peter Deane

... Lesbians - when only the brest will do.
--- Plutonic 2.13 #1
 * Origin: Inquestor. Hydra for TrapDoor, THANX! +61-43-961587 (3:711/476)