From David Jones · 1996-04-03 07:18 · #77247 in CB_RADIO
Noticed Richard Town's message to David Jones about Nhs Waiting Lists RT> Didn't make myself sufficiently clear then. The proposition is that RT> the insurance companies should provide health service cover, as a RT> financial operation only, for those able to afford it. For those RT> unable to afford it then there would be a sliding scale of subsidy RT> based on ability to pay, funded as of now (taxation and "stamp") And the consequence of that would be the end of consensus for a tax-funded health service. DJ> Even a perfectly competitive insurance market could not be relied DJ> upon to be equitable. RT> Nothing is perfectly equitable. Despite the over-reaching state under RT> either political control there's still drop-outs 2 Points. The only argument for the free market is its supposed efficiency. The models which pupport to demonstrate this are based on ideal markets which have /nothing/ much to do with the real world; so why do you support extending private enterprise to the NHS? Secondly, people dropping out has nothing at all to do with whether the system's equitable or not. RT> Sounds like current Walworth Road speak to me, with a dash of LSE RT> bitters! Oh, right. Good argument there. RT> OTOH, if you believe your value-set empirical judgements RT> don't co-incide with the Doner-Richter model... And if you want to bandy names, try reading LeGrand (LSE I'm afraid), 'Equity and Choice'. ___ Blue Wave/QWK v2.12 --- WILDMAIL!/WC v4.12 * Origin: Ooh! BBS, London [MULTILINES] 0181-395-3108 (2:254/233.0)