From John Dowson · 1996-03-09 18:11 · #77224 in CB_RADIO
Hi Dave, I opened my mailbox and saw your reply to my reply to Kaz's
message. Remember? I said:
JD> Now there is where I disagree. As soon as we start to use our
JD> defence resources against the population - especially for
JD> political ends such as strike-breaking - then we abuse the power
JD> of government and deserve the civil insurrection which usually
JD> results.
You said:
DL >>We were used to prevent deaths...and we did rather better than anyone thought
>>we would. In no way did our work 'break' any strike, nor devalue their
>>political end
I was not criticising the service you and many others provided - It was
superb by any standards. You will remember Kaz's original comment was
that defence spending was necessary to provide for contingency services
in case of strike. It was here I took issue. Defence spending should
be for defence. My comment criticised this and any other government
of whatever colour who is willing to use its defence resources against
the genral public in what is a legitimate disagreement with the
government itself.ÿ
We then went on with:
JD> This is, of course, a different matter and it is perfectly
JD> legitimate to use defence forces to help recover from natural
JD> disasters which are a threat in themselves.
DL >>It's no different. Help to the public, no matter what the reason, is
>>a valid use of the Defence Forces, IMO.
If we substitute "Public Services" for "Defence Forces" then you and I
would find ourselves in complete agreement. IMHO you shouldn't use
Benefits Agency staff to fight fires or the Fire Service to dispense
Housing Benefit. Similarly, the Defence Forces should be trained and
held in readiness for what we need them to do - defend us against
external aggression or threat.
Regards,
John [John.Dowson@wlink.co.uk]
* 1st 2.00 #8597 * Excuse me Sysop but: I have "SET TEMPERATURE=C:\DOS"
--- PCBoard (R) v15.22/M 100
* Origin: Message Sent via WorldLink BBS Systems, Derby U.K. (2:2503/110)