From Stuart Presnell · 1996-04-14 20:10 · #76706 in AMIGA_VIDEO
In reply to Evans reply to you by Gary Depietro
Hello Gary! I address this message to Evan Soule and Joseph Newman. Please do not take this message as a personal attack - I may attack your actions, but I do not intend to insult /you/ in any way. 02 Apr 96 06:26, Evan Soule, via Gary Depietro, wrote to Ken Stuckas: I shan't quote the whole message here - that would serve no purpose. GD> To Stuckas(SENO): Evan, what do you mean by (SENO) ? It is no acronym that I have heard of. ES> The only "folly" is the folly of your own claims ES> Lies and "disinformation" are your products. ES> I would suggest that Gary spend a portion of his money on aspirin ES> for the headaches caused him by your repeated lies. JN> Stuckas: You are an idiot, a coward, and a liar. I find this amazing. Evan sends a message of about 4 or 5 Kb (by my guess), containing no real information whatsoever. Considering that you accuse Ken of dealing in "lies and disinformation", you seem to be doing a pretty good job of evading the issue yourself. This attack against Ken does nothing to aid the case you present - namely that Mr Newman's machine performs as has been claimed. It acts simply to distract attention from his legitimate questions, and avoid answering them. >> KS> If he can put more power out of his >> KS> machine than is required to run it, then the batteries >> KS> are irrelevant. All he would need to do is to give >> KS> it a spin by hand and it would continue to run without >> KS> the batteries. It will not. GD> _________________________ GD> To Stuckas(SENO): GD> This comment only proves that you do not understand the GD> technology. Evan Soule Evan, I apologise for my ignorance, but could you answer this question for me: Does the machine, in any real way, give out more energy than it takes in, over the long term? And if I may, a second question to follow it: IF the machine puts out more energy than it takes in, does this mean that the output can be poured back into the input, while tapping off the excess? Explaining these two points would help me (and possibly everyone else in the SCIENCE echo) understand just what Mr Newman's invention is capable of. JN> Reply by Joseph Newman: JN> Even a typical service-station mechanic knows that he can check JN> the voltage across a battery or battery pack and instantly know JN> whether the battery is being charged or discharged. I don't know much about electricity, I'll admit, but this insistance on measuring the voltage rise seems... suspicious. If the device is genuine, surely it will pass /any/ fair test? Is the Locked-Room Test not a fair one? JN> In addition, the article (as previously presented) from the American JN> Physics Journal totally proves that the technology I teach throughout my JN> book is correct Which article is this? I recall Gary Depietro posting a long message which included a few graphs and figures, but I did not follow the working. Is this the one to which you refer? JN> and that you are wrong To be wrong is no dishonour. But to show Ken is wrong, why not accept his challenge. He has been demanding that you put your device through the test for weeks - wouldn't it wipe the smile off Stukas' stupid face when the machine passes, and shows his error to the world! [No real insult intended, Ken :) ] JN> as well as being an idiot, This is an ad hominem attack (one of many from you and Evan Soule, I might add). The fact that Ken disagreees with your ideas, despite what evidence you present, does not make him an "idiot", any more than you would accept such an insult for disagreeing with thousands of scientists. JN> a coward, Are you calling Ken a "coward" for refusing your challenge? In that case, I challenge you to throw your machine from a fifth-storey window. If it is genuine, it will not fall to the ground. If you refuse this test (which I assure you is fair), you are a coward. You see? Refusing a meaningless test does not make one a coward. JN> and a liar! Ken would be lying if he /deliberately/ said things he knew to be untrue. Do you believe this to be the case? He is simply stating the facts as he understands them, which we assume you are also doing. Just because one of you is wrong (since you contradict each other), that does not mean that anyone is neccesarily lying. Do you have evidence to prove your allegations against Mr Stukas? Answer the questions which science demands of your machine, or science must reject it. It's as simple as that. SmP --- GEcho 1.00 * Origin: SmP's Point off Pacific Lightning BBS (2:440/7.46)