From Morris Shaw · 1996-04-03 20:14 · #76665 in AMIGA_VIDEO
On 04-01-96 RON FREIMUTH wrote to KEN STUCKAS...
KS> I asked him if he believed that Newman's machine would
> pass the (now famous) locked room test and he said yes
> but that there were still a few problems to be overcome
> with the batteries.
RF>
RF> Some pages I got from Gary (copied out of the Book) show current
RF> waveforms, and give some additional info on how long the batteries
RF> last. Chapter 6 contains a description of a unit with 145 lbs of #30
RF> wire and a 14 lb rotating magnet.
RF>
I see this device as having the magnet on an axle along the
diameter of the coil and the magnet rotating in a plane perpendic-
ular to the axle and the coil. Is this correct?
RF> Dr. Hastings made some measurements on it in 1984 and a copy of his
RF> signed and notarized affidavit is in the book. He measured the RMS
RF> running current by measuring the temperature rise of a 500 ohm
RF> resistor in a water bath. A DC current of 14 ma. gave about the
RF> same dT/dt; this was a calibration check.
RF>
RF> The DC current into the motor was measured at 1.4 ma. These
RF> current values and ratios are similar to measurements for other
RF> devices. Where a large negative pulse of current reduces the
RF> average battery current to a low value. But, means rms/dc is
RF> quite high.
Every description seems to indicate that standard definitions
of rms are tricky to apply as well as measure. And seems to be one
way of showing increased efficiency and "proving" deficiencies in
current physics.
RF> Most AC ammeters measure true RMS current (AC voltmeters often do
RF> not measure true RMS, except on a sine wave). So does my Fluke (it
RF> appears Newman had a Fluke similar or identical to my unit at his
RF> site - perhaps after this test). One has to be careful with meters,
RF> they can clip waveforms. A resistor doesn't - unless it opens up.
Sample rates with digital meters don't always show the little
transients that can reveal quite a bit. The o'scope might help a
bit on this.
RF> The coil measured 50K Ohm DC resistance. Thus, 0.014^2 * 50K =
RF> 10W copper loss. That sounds reasonable. Though, I'd require a
RF> properly used True RMS meter reading for good accuracy.
RF>
RF> The motor was stated to run at 136 rpm. This is consistent with
RF> what many different Newman machines seemed to run at in the Video.
RF> Not fast, but still at a significant speed.
RF>
Which gives us 2.27 Hz for figuring an rms from the DC measures.
RF> It looks like 304 VDC was supplied by 9V batteries.
RF>
RF> A fresh 9V battery was drained at 14 ma, it was found the voltage
RF> dropped 2%/hr. In contrast, the full set of 9 V batteries ran the
RF> above motor for four hours 'and the voltage remained constant at 304
RF> V'.
RF>
RF> It looks like 34 batteries would develop 304 Volts. I think a
RF> '9 V alkaline transistor battery' can supply about 100 mA-hr. You
RF> mentioned 20W/lb for alkaline cells.
RF>
RF> The motor did not produce any useful output (well, it would cause
RF> a '75 watt' fluorescent lamp placed across the coil to glow at 'about
RF> 10% of full brightness'.
RF>
RF> Hastings comments that the input power is 1.4 ma * 304 VDC = 0.36W.
RF> While the I^2 R loss in the coil is 1.4ma^2 * 50,000 ohm = 10 W.
RF>
RF> Where is that 10 Watts coming from? This doesn't even cover the
RF> likely much larger power required to run spin the magnet at 136 rpm.
RF>
RF> A 14 lb cylindrical magnet (from the picture, its length is about
RF> twice the diameter) develops a lot of wind resistance at 136 rpm).
RF> The pictures do not have a scale by them, you might figure out how
RF> large a cylinder of say Alnico (my guess) weighing 14 lbs would be.
RF> Then, figure how much power it would take to run it at 136 rpm.
RF>
But we only need to get it moving with the 10W draw for up to
one-half of the duty cycle. Once spinning at full speed the current
draw is for frictive losses. I don't see any measurements of current
draw for starting this thing, just steady run. If the rotor is given
a spin by hand there is an incredible power savings!
RF> If one 9V battery can supply about 0.1*9 = 0.9 W-hr, then 34 could
RF> supply 31 W-hr. Hastings stated the voltage didn't drop over four
RF> hours of running, and that Newman had been using the same batteries
RF> for long demonstrations over several months.
RF>
RF> That would be consistent with an effective current drain of 1.4
RF> ma, what was measured.
RF>
RF> So, Ken:
RF>
RF> EXPLAIN WHERE THE POWER DEVELOPED IN THE COIL RESISTANCE, and even
RF> more, IN TURNING THE MAGNET, CAME FROM.
RF>
Well, I'm not Ken but I think I can make a positive contribution.
The machine is not like a standard dc motor where one has a steady
magnetic push throughout a revolution on the rotor so dc approximates
rms. Nothing is done with the induced currents in the unused windings
still moving in the magnetic field. Newman seems to be using this
"free energy" to "overcharge" his batteries.
In any case, despite using a dc power source it may be more
useful and correct to use ac power measurements and analyses. The
rise time of the field in the coil may prevent the current from ever
reaching saturation. Gary (or Evan?) mentions adjustment of the com-
mutators to regulate the rotational speed, in other words adjusting
the duty cycle. Starting with the magnet parallel to the coil, I
would cut current when the magnet was perpendicular to the coil, ie
aligned with the magnetic field. Let it coast until close to being
parallel again and sample the coil as the magnet poles passed the
coil. After this back emf(?) kick, the battery current would flow
again to give the rotor/magnet another kick.
RF> Guess you will have to GET The BOOK<g> if you want to see a few
RF> details of the tests.
Ron, you're almost starting to sound like an apologist for
Newman's machine!
morris
---
* OFFLINE 1.56 * ... Did you expect mere proof to sway my opinion?
--- FLAME v1.0
* Origin: L.A. Valley College BBS <@Support.COM> (818)985-7150 (1:102/837)