Slimelite BBS

Moon Structures

Back to AMIGA_VIDEO

From Jeff Sterling · 1996-04-02 16:22 · #76656 in AMIGA_VIDEO

BPL> NASA hasn't been hiding a damn thing.  There are an immense
BPL> number of telescopes around the world, probably on the order of
BPL> 10^5, and a fair number of large telescopes.  The "moon
BPL> structures" are optical illusions which show up _only in small
BPL> telescopes_ and _only at certain angles of illumination._
BPL> Because they aren't seen on Moon photos from U.S. spaceprobes
BPL> (or Japanese, European or Soviet spaceprobes), the Moon Machine
BPL> freaks immediately assume it's a NASA conspiracy -- not that
BPL> their own observations are wrong.  I suppose I shouldn't be
BPL> infuriated by this assinine pseudoscience, but it begins to
BPL> grate after a while.

Interesting.  I find myself in the peculiar position of defending the
"Moon Machine freaks" even though I agree with your conclusions.
Why?  Because you have reached your conclusions in entirely the wrong
way!

You apparently gave one cursory glance at the subject of the "Moon
Structures" message and formed your opinion without actually reading
a single word of it!  First of all, had you read even the first few
lines of that message, you would have seen that that message came to
you curtesy of Donald Hines.  I only forwarded the message to the
echo because Donald sent it to me first in netmail, in order to ask
if it fell within the guidlines of the echo for on-topic subjects.

The real giveaway that you did not read the message, though, is your
statement that "they aren't seen on Moon photos from U.S.
spaceprobes."  Every single photograph that message was based upon
was from a U.S. lunar probe or manned Apollo mission.  The NASA
catalog numbers were given for each and every one.

I agree that NASA is not guilty of "hiding" anything, because every
one of the photographs is available to the general public from NASA.
All you have to do is order them using the catalog numbers provided.

I also agree that the "structures" are probably optical illusions (or
imaging artifacts, or misinterpretations), however I have not seen
the photos in question so I shall reserve my final judgement.  You,
however, have formed your opinion not only without looking at the
"evidence," but without even reading the proposal!  This is what
gives mainstream science a bad name.

You are playing right into the hands of the pseudo-scientists (if
that is what they are) by refusing to even consider the photographs
in question.  When they point to messages like yours and cry "closed-
minded" and "biased" they will be absolutely correct and 100%
justified in their resentment!  That is not the way to bolster the
cause of true science.  The correct way to debunk the bad science is
to look at the evidence and show where it has been misinterpreted or
maybe even doctored in order to support the conclusions they have
reached.  The evidence they base their conclusions on -IS- available
to you.  That is one reason I allowed the post to be made here.  You
can order the photographs from NASA, look at them yourself and arrive
at your OWN conclusions based upon the evidence at hand rather than
making a knee-jerk reaction to the mere nature of the hypothesis.

You do the cause of science no favors by rejecting this out-of-hand,
even if it is bad science (-especially- if it is bad science)!

P.S.  I have no problem with those who do not wish to waste their
time looking at the so called evidence, as long as they remain mute
on the subject.  If, however, you wish to vociferously proclaim the
evidence is bogus, you -must- at least LOOK at the evidence first!

 * OLX 2.1 * Getting good results by hocus-pocus is frowned upon. --RF
--- 
 * Origin: The Bear's Cave Titusville FL 407-383-9372 V34/VFC/H16 (1:374/73)