Slimelite BBS

Re: STP

Back to AMIGA_VIDEO

From Ron Freimuth · 1996-04-03 08:51 · #76649 in AMIGA_VIDEO

LR>PR>KS|o|        The snake oil salesmen are still with us.  Remember
  >  >  |o|        Andy Granatelli and STP?

LR> RF>    It increases the viscosity of engine oil so in cold weather it takes
  > RF>  longer to get a good oil flow.  Probably causing more harm than good.

LR>     If one starts one's car in cold weather.  I rarely do, since cold
  >weather is rare hereabouts.

    Not this winter!  Are you an STP <giggle> fan, Leslie?  You should
 read that old Consumer's Report.  The STP stock really dropped after it
 came out. ;-)

    Now, I did try STP in my air cooled Honda.  The clutch grabbed with
 the recommended oil.  But, with STP it slipped.

LR> RF>     This of this: if a more thixotropic property were desirable for
  > RF>  engine oil it would be part of the manufacter's specification.

LR>        I'm not sure why you would say that.  Engine manufacturers do not
  >really want their engines to last much beyond warranty.

    I'd question that.  People don't purchase new vehicles because the
 engine is worn out.  Except for me. ;-)

    Auto manufacturers do tend to recommend fewer lube changes than
 desirable if one wants to get really long life.  Especially for the
 transmission, power steering, etc.  Where no recommended changes are
 typical.

    I only change my oil every couple of years now.  I use synthetic oil
 and only drive a couple of thousand miles a year.  I changed the oil in
 my '66 F-85 as recommended: every 2 months. <g> The engine was only
 getting broken in at 70,000 miles.  Really - the oil consumption was on
 the high side before then.


    Hot starting is supposed to be severe. The oil on the pistons gets
 hot after an engine is stopped since heat soaks from the piston to the
 rings.  This thins the oil, it tends to run off. Since the rings are
 the major source of friction in an engine hot starts draw a lot of
 starter current.

    Something like STP might improve hot start performance.  Anyway,
 it's really only a Viscosity Index enhancer.  You get that compounded
 into the multigrade oils.  Which start with a thin enough base so the
 lubricant doesn't end up too thick.

    I've never had a problem with hot starts.  Not near the problem of
 cold weather starts, where the battery is limited in output.

LR> RF>    The only oil additive recommended by GM (ca ~1960) was a detergency
  > RF>  increasing additive for severe service.

LR>just that.  However, no manufacturer is going to deliberately recommend a thi
  >party product which potentially cuts their profits significantly.

    Maybe Ken S. will have something more to say.

    Engine oils have been improved considerably over the ages.  Acid
 corrosion used to be a significant problem.  It rarely is nowadays.
 The various oil specifications were set by auto manufacturers.  If they
 weren't concerned with acid pitting, etc. they wouldn't have specified
 anti-corrosion performance, etc.

---
 * OLX 2.1 TD * Power corrupts. Absolute power is great!
--- FidoPCB v1.5 beta-'j'
 * Origin: Lunatic Fringe * Richardson,TX * 214-235-5288 * (1:124/2113)