Slimelite BBS

Ok, Let'S Speculate... ;)

Back to AMIGA_VIDEO

From Herman Trivilino · 1996-04-03 15:06 · #76628 in AMIGA_VIDEO

In reply to Ok, Let'S Speculate... ;) by Jeff Sterling

On (02 Apr 96) Jeff Sterling wrote to Sol Steinberg...

SS> JS>According to the equations of GR, a singularity is where the
SS> JS>equations of GR fail.  GR cannot predict what happens at a
SS> JS>singularity, by definition.

SS> I suggest that if you take the limits as you approach the
SS> singularity, you will get the result I have stated.

The result you get is nonsense.  The equations of GR fail, but
this failure results from the fact that the equations are being
used outside the limits of validity of the theory.  Specifically,
the entire theory of GR is a nonquantum theory, so we expect the
equations to be valid only in the nonquantum limit.  Normally,
gravity is so weak that the nonquantum approximation is easily
satisfied.  However, as one approaches the point source of a
gravitational field, the approximation is no longer valid, (the
graviational field strength is too large).  Unfortunately, there
is no accepted theory that will predict the behavior of nature in
this area.  In other words, there are theories, but without
experimental evidence there is no way to decide which, if any, of
the theories of quantum gravity make accurate predictions.

 JS> ...and if you "take the limits" of a pair of parallel lines on an
 JS> Euclidean plane you will reach the conclusion that the lines
 JS> "intersect" (at infinity).  Does that make the conclusion correct?

Actually, if you assume the space is Euclidean, the separation
distance between the lines remains constant, regardless of how
far along the lines one travels.


--- PPoint 2.00
 * Origin: A Dimensionless Point in Houston, Texas (1:106/2000.7)