From Larry Bevard · 1996-04-03 04:39 · #76618 in AMIGA_VIDEO
Hi again Ron,
RF>It's hard to get much real news nowadays unless one reads speciality
RF>magazines. Though, The Wall Street Journal and Christian Science
RF>Monitor are supposed to be pretty good.
RF>
RF>Still, without TV individuals would have even less of an idea of
RF>what is happening. Actually, it might be better to be ignorant than
RF>'just a little informed'.
I tend to agree. Too many people take the 2 min. bit of news as
gospil and the whole story. Even some of the longer (5 min) stories
presents only one very biased view of the story. For example of bad
reporting, last summer NBC did a report on "Promise Keepers". There
whole story was based on the fact that it did not allow women into the
'club'. They just mentioned the purpose of PK, and then only very
indirectly. Yet it left even me, some one who knows something about PK,
with the thought that these were a bunch of religious fanatic, male
chovinistic, suprimist, out to take over the government. ABC did the
same thing in a 20 Min spot on "Focus on the Family". If you look at
the way the press has treated Ragan, Bush and Clinton, you can see where
every fault of Ragan and Bush was exposed, but When Clinton says one
thing one week and then the opposite the next, is there any discussion? No.
RF>It's rather discouraging to consider what seems to work on TV:
RF>typical ads and political spots. Shows that most viewers are emotion,
RF>rather than reality based. Sometimes I analyse ads to see just what
RF>they DON'T say. For example, Accura mentions precision. Nowhere is it
RF>claimed the autos are more 'precise' that the competition. Not
RF>surprising, because there is little reason to believe their autos are.
RF>But, people apparently supposed to associate a word with positive
RF>connotation, 'precision' with the Auto. ;-)
RF>
RF>The fact that those dumb magazine contests must work, or they
RF>wouldn't be used, shows how typical people fall for what is implied,
RF>but not true.
RF>
RF>When I see a 'We hope you win' I think, 'They are saying the same
RF>thing to everyone!'. Meaningless.
RF>
RF>Now and then I calculate the Expected Return vs the cost of a stamp.
RF>Of course, you loose, not counting your time.
Bartum said that there is a sucker born every minute, and I think he
is right. Just look at how many people by lotto tickets and what the
odds are at winning. Even when you show them the odds, all they say is
that your a fool to play and a fool if you don't.
RF>>to intertaining in order to succeed, so a lot of the information is
RF>>taken out. Even the longer commitaries suffer from this. And above
RF>>all, we only get one view point from the TV news.
RF>
RF>Further, what is reported is sometimes biased. A friend of mine
RF>found how scientific reports are often judged by the abstract/summary,
RF>not the contents. Which may not support the summary. The summary is
RF>written to support what the funding agency wants to see in many cases.
RF>If it didn't - no more funding. <g>
One of the bible lessions I am working on now has to do with the
"fast food" mind set that this nation has. Kids think nouthing of
putting 50 cents in a video game that last for the average of 1 1/2 min.
and calling it a good time. My kids when they were littler loved
watching commercials, they only lasted 30 sec. and gave a complete
message, none of this 5 min stuff for them. They still have problems
watching anything over 10 min. Most adults are getting the same way,
they want there imformation NOW and short and sweet, none of this
indepth studies for them, give me the bottom line.
The question is then how to get out of this trap we are in, or are
we stuck with a bunch of people that takes their information in short
packets and allow 2% of the people to decide what the learn?
RF>LB> The same thing goes for any value system, even the Christian right.
RF>>Eventhough I think the Christian way is a better way, I would not feel
RF>>free to force these values on others to the exclusion of critical
RF>>thinking any more that I appreciate the schools forcing a PC value
RF>>system on my Kids. But, under either system certain values need to be
RF>>taught like responsiblity for self, respect for others, moral
RF>>responsiblity. These things are missing from our schools and our society.
RF>
RF>I'm not sure why. Lots of possible reasons. I heard that A students
RF>are sometimes as badly behaved as the D & F students.
Again, a lot of it has to do with leveling the classes. I don't
think it is wrong to teach different kids with different interest and
different abbilities, different things. Kids that can handle higher
standard and more critical thinking needs to be taught that, Kids that
can't handle that type of teaching needs to be taught at a level they
can understand and excel in. My daughter is signing up for classes in
11th grade now, and the teacher told her that there is no difference
between Algebra A and B, they are the same. What they are suppose to be
is A is for college bond, B is for others.
RF>LB> I used this as an example, brought about by the discussion in Tenn.
RF>>of again banning Evolution from being taught in biology. I agree will
RF>>everyone in that pure creationism as most people understands it is bad
RF>>science. But, there are also some points or evolution that is bad
RF>>science. By examining both, the students learn what science is all
RF>
RF>Well, talking about Creationism as an example of bad science would
RF>also be a value judgment. One that many would complain about.
RF>Regardless, there are plenty of examples of bad science, especially in
RF>biology. The trouble with mentioning too much of it is that kids might
RF>then figure it's all bad. ;-)
But one thing it does do is to demostrate the thought that there is
no absolutes in science, something most non-science students don't know.
There are faults in creationism as well as evolution in terms of
explaining it all. One of the things I use to do when teaching Physics
is to compare the earth-center and sun-centered solar system theories
and examine why they were both valid theories. This taught the kids
that there is a process and that these ideas were not unchanging laws
only representives of what we see.
Larry Bevard
___
* UniQWK v4.1 * The Windows Mail Reader
--- PCBoard (R) v15.22/M 5
* Origin: 1:3615/50 (1:3615/51)