Slimelite BBS

Re: Speed of Gravity

Back to AMIGA_VIDEO

From David Henderson · 1996-04-01 22:43 · #76529 in AMIGA_VIDEO

In reply to Speed of Gravity by Ron Freimuth

Ladies and Gentlemen, your appretiation please for JIM DAVIS and KARL LEMBKE: 
 KL>> If the particle known as the graviton, the particle that mediates
 JD> gravity,
 KL>> turns out to exist, the speed of light will be the fastest it can
 KL>> travel. And if it turns out to be a massless particle, the speed of
 KL>> light will also be the SLOWEST it can travel.
 JD> 
 JD> I'm sure I'm not the only one to consider this, so it must have
 JD> been thought through by someone, otherwise the concept of gravitons,
 JD> gravity particles, quantized gravity packets or whatever would have
 JD> been dropped. Anyone who knows a reasonable argument against my
 JD> thoughts, please educate me.
 JD> 
 JD> If gravity is mediated by particles in motion from an object of mass,
 JD>  and moves no faster than the speed of light, then how does a black
 JD> hole demonstrate any form of gravitational attraction to neighboring
 JD> bodies. It would seem the particle of gravity could not escape, since
 JD> it would not be achieving escape velocity.

Sorry if this is old hat, but is it not best to consider that particles with mass affect the geometry of space-time (warp it in other words) and thus gravitational effects are merely consequeces of bodies taking the energetically favourable route though space-time.
This gives the impression of a infinitly rapidly propigating 3D force.

If gravity can indeed overcome light as in a black hole, surely this points us to this conclusion.

Any takers?


Yours etc.

David.
  90:104/115@nest.ftn   2:440/375.3@fidonet.org
  dhend@rmplc.co.uk

... 98 percent of all statistics are made up.

--- IOS-Mail 0.91pl6 áeta
 * Origin: Ashford International Building Site II (2:440/375.3)