Slimelite BBS

Newmans machine debate

Back to AMIGA_VIDEO

From Glen Beestone · 1996-04-01 05:41 · #76526 in AMIGA_VIDEO

Hi Jeff,

Although I have cast my vote on this subject there is one thing I want to 
add. I did vote for the thread to continue as I don't like the idea of
censoring a subject just because it's not popular.
However the real test of this should be, is it SCIENCE. From what I've seen 
lately theres been precious little science and the posts have degenerated 
into:

Newmnan/Gary/Evan: "Video tape, credible witnesses, video tape credible 
witnesses, vwitnesses etc etc.

Ken: "Locked room test, locked room test, locked....

You get the picture i'm sure.

Unless Even or Newman post some schematics and theory via Gary or agree to a 
test, all were going to get from now on is the above chanting. By test I mean 
a proper scientific test such as Ken is proposing. By insisting on  his own 
test rules Joe Newman is making himself look highly suspect. It's tantamount
to the magician syaing "Of course you can search for hidden tricks, only so 
long as you don't look up my sleeve". This is a SCIENCE echo not a MYSTICAL
FORCES echo and the onus is on Newman to show that his machine is doing
soemething amazing by proving it scientifically. Unless he can do that it's
not really a SCIENCE topic is it ? 
Banning the thread isn't a case of censorship or conspiracy to supress 
information It's a case of relavancy. He wouldn't be allowed to ply his 
trade in COOKING or HIKING and unless it's SCIENCE he shouldn't be allowed 
to do it here.


Cheers,

Glen.

... "Explain again how sheep bladders may be used to stop earthquakes?"
--- GEcho 1.11+
 * Origin: The Hard Rock Studio - South Shields 0191 4569135 (2:256/505)