Slimelite BBS

Newman's Theory/Test

Back to AMIGA_VIDEO

From Ron Freimuth · 1996-03-29 10:21 · #76497 in AMIGA_VIDEO

CL> GD> Using 30 gauge copper wire with .1 ohm resistance per foot [each
  > GD> turn of wire consisting of 1 ft. of 30 gauge wire], the following
  > GD> facts are shown if one uses a battery power source of 1.5 volts
  > GD> producing only a maximum of one amp:

CL>At last!  Some figures to get hold of!

CL> GD> 1.5 volts TIMES 1 amp EQUALS 1.5 watts input power going through 1
  > GD> turn of 30 gauge wire EQUALS 1 amp turn strength of magnetic field
  > GD> produced.

CL>What strange units, "amp turn(s) strength..."!  I much prefer to measure my
  >magnetic flux density [MFD] ("strength of magnetic field") in Tesla.

    Amperes/m are the units of H.  Thus, Ampere Turns are a common
 product in coil design.  I never heard of 'MFD', I use B.  One Tesla is
 one Wb/m^2.

CL>Anyway, this 1 turn (or n turns) of wire of one foot (!) in
  >circumference will have a radius of approx 49mm => 0.049m.  Tell

CL>The resistance of 1 turn is 0.1 Ohm.  This 'coil' will draw 1.5 / 0.1
  >= 15 Amps >of current from the battery BUT the battery will only
  >supply 1A and the input voltage will drop significantly.

    .........

CL>The resistance of 100 turns is 10 Ohms.  Now the coil will draw
  > 1.5 / 10 = 0.15 A and the battery will supply it.
 ..............

CL> GD> CONCLUSION:  Observe that the current and watts input consistently
  > GD> DECREASES as the number of turns of atoms comprising the coil
  > GD> INCREASES and yet the strength of the magnetic field produced never
  > GD> decreases.

    You seem to have achieved the correct result.  As one adds turns to
 a coil, it's resistance varies with NR.  NI stays constant.  The drop
 in I is exactly balanced by the increase in N.

    I just say Newman's video demonstration.  Where he used two 9V
 transistor batteries on two different spools of #10 wire.  Twenty and
 eighty lbs.  Now, the internal resistance of one 9V battery is about
 three ohms.  Thus, the current can't be much higher than 18/6 = 3A on a
 dead short.

    The resistance of the coils of wire is only a few ohms.  I found the
 actual value a while back.

    If a *constant* voltage were applied to both coils, *and* if the
 geometry of the coils didn't change, then H would be the same for
 either coil.  Since the current doesn't increase much for fewer turns
 because of the batteries internal resistance the condition is not
 satisfied.  Thus, the coil with more turns generates a stronger field.

    It looked like the current the ammeter showed was about 2.5 A with
 the small coil, and half that for the larger one.  Since the number of
 turns increase by more than 2:1, the pointer should move more on the
 second coil.  As it did.

    Newman doesn't seem to understand this.  And, he based his
 continuing work on it, and other errors.  Heck, he's been at this since
 1965.

---
 * OLX 2.1 TD * Education is a poor substitute for cognition
--- FidoPCB v1.5 beta-'j'
 * Origin: Lunatic Fringe * Richardson,TX * 214-235-5288 * (1:124/2113)