Slimelite BBS

Re: Recall rulings

Back to Q&Q

From mrmarcel@bnr.csc.ncsu.edu · 1996-03-27 23:56 · #76449 in Q&Q

From: mrmarcel@bnr.csc.ncsu.edu (Mike Marcelais)

My spies tell me that Ingo Warnke (nfa031@hp1.uni-rostock.de) wrote:
| John Garrett (John@sagames.demon.co.uk) wrote:
| : In article <4ig8ah$4bn@taco.cc.ncsu.edu>
| :            mrmarcel@eos.ncsu.edu "Mike Marcelais" writes:

| : > My spies tell me that Paul Barclay (pb207@hermes.cam.ac.uk) wrote:
| : > | If Recall is countered, do you still lost the cards that you would
| : > | have discarded anyway? 
| : > 
| : > No.  Discarding cards is part of the effect.  If Recall is countered,
| : > you never get to the part about discarding.
| : > 
| : Neil,
| :     can you give a ruling on this - it has been (and reluctantly I've
| : followed suit) ruled that the cards have been discarded on countering at the 
| : last 3 sanctioned events in the UK (by WotC reps/staff).
| : I am unhappy about the ruling - but will apply an 'official' line when I judge.

| I know of no spell that has a discard at the cost. The rulings file says:
|   Choose which cards to discard when announced, discard them on resolution.
|       [Duelist Magazine #6, Page 131]

| Both this file and the Duelist are not official, but there is no other
| indication why Recall should be an exception to the rule.

Actually, the Duelist is an official source of rules information since it
is published by WotC.
--

+------------------------+----------------------------+
|  Mike Marcelais        | mrmarcel@eos.ncsu.edu      |
|  Moonstone Dragon      | Magic: The Gathering Judge |
|  -==(UDIC)==-          | Author of ChrHack 2.3      |
+-----------------------------------------------------+

---
 * Origin: SEUK Mail Server, Guildford, Uk 44-1483-821184 (2:440/3.0)