From Paul West · 1996-04-11 00:33 · #76424 in APRIL
In reply to Newbie by Jeff Chesney
On 06-Apr-96, something quite extraordinary happened. You revealed to All that it was to do with "Newbie"! Jolly good show Jeff! JC> Hello eveyone, Hi. JC> Seeing that I am new to this echo, and a foriegner to Philosophy I JC> thought that I would just like to ask, and I'll proberbly reget it JC> later, JC> What is Philosophy.__What is its Use.__Is it a waste of Time ? Would I be being philosphical to say that you're gunna get a whole variety of answers to those questions? ;-) It's a bit hard to define philosphy because it is to do with defining other things. So it sort of inherits this questionability and uncertainty and so on. I personally don't think you can actually call something philosophy because of the way that evolution works. Every facet of life is to do with the dispersal and loss of energy. This includes watching TV, doing a sport, doing a job, whatever. So it also includes philosophy. It's about growth, learning, understanding the world and cosmos. It's kind of like a little package containing every part of life, and it can apply to absolutely anything whatsoever as far as I am concerned. So some might say you can philosphise about what flavour drink you'll have, or what TV program you like, or whatever. Depiste this, there is a general global trend towars partiality, at the moment. In other words, there aren't many philosphies based on `wholeness' or total unity. Because of this unwholeness various different philosphies act to `filter out' some things and `filter in' others, allowing rational conclusions to be attempted. So it's highly debatable as to wether or not a philosophy based on wholeness, such as infinity, is actually a `philosophy'. My mum and dad particularly have this notion that I am philsophising about stuff all the time, and I keep telling them no. I say no because my `philosophy' isn't based on partiality, and so cannot truly be given a label. However, my philosophy, which is based on infinity, encompasses also all the things in life, all the TV program choices, flavours of drink, and so on. So you could still perhaps call it philosophy because by all intents and purposes it is basically the same. But I do believe that for a philosophy to be true it has to be as whole and `unified' as possible. You often hear of there being a unified theory in physics or whatever. The more united the fundamental principles are the more things are within its scope of explaining. So the unity I use is the ultimate unity, infinity. Unfortunately not a lot of other people do this, and tend to base their truth on what is tangible, which is a total opposite to what I do. So not many people understand what I'm going on about or why what I say is true. So that's philosophy for me, if you can truly call it that. It is certainly useful yes, but no moreso than any other aspect of life. In the end choosing a TV program to watch is useful for evolution, just as is philosophising. It tends to be that philosophy sort of concentrates on big-picture matters, like God and afterlife and stuff like that, things which berhaps are part of a `beyond'. The problem is that those who use tangibility as their truth are inherantly blind to seeing any kind of a beyond, so you will see various people questioning things like the existence of God. What they're actually doing is assuming that they already know what God is, and then questioning wether he exists. Their questions, however, would only be valid if they first found out fully what God was and then questioned. So you can see a bit of a paradox there. IMO everything is paradoxical in some way. I suppose for me `philosophy' is just an extension of life, of learning and growing. I'm kind of naturally the sort of person to question and want to learn and stuff like that, and so I get shoved into the category of philosopher quite often. But apart from such labels I'm still just me with my interest in the truth just like anyone else, and I think that's about the most general definition of what philosophy is and why people do it. JC> It seems to me at this pre-introductory stage to Philosophy that to be JC> a Philosopher or to Philosophise, one but needs only to be able to JC> "Waffle" in such a way as to Baffle ones (lets say) Opponent into JC> mental Submission. hehehe. That does seem to occur quite a bit. But, that people get baffled doesn't mean that it was done intentionally. For example, just because you might find a stone at the side of a road it doesn't mean it chose to go there. Let's not confuse the arrival of something with its choosing to go there. So on the outside there is a lot of waffle yes, but inside people are genuinly trying to present their version of perception. Unfortunately because we all have different versions of perception there is very often a lot of problem trying to understand what OTHER people's version is, and generally we only get a vague idea unless the two are very similar. Say you were to hold a piece of transparent red plastic in front of your eyes, which makes everything you see through it appear to be shades of red. Now if you go looking at something which in truth is the colour Green, you will see that it is Red. Thus your red philosophy filters out the things which are Green. IOW, if something is beyond your perception, or beyond your understanding of `Truth', it renders you blind to seeing `other' truth. This is also why partiality always ensures an unwhole philosophy, or one which says such-and-such is true, such-and-such is false. If you see red through red you say it's true, if you see green through red you say it's false. That's the basic property which allows you to say at any point that something is true or false. Now as far as my philosophy is concerned, that it is based on infinity means there is no `other' situation, there is no `beyond' it, no outside. So it can and does encompass all philosophies and does NOT allow blindness of understanding. Whereas the red-eyed person can only see red, and the green-eyed only green, the full-spectrum-eyed person sees it all. This is why truly infinity is the only true whole truth, and that is what I based my `philosophy' on. I personally have found that by using infinity you can see where things contradict themselves, such as seeing why a red filter doesn't allow you to see green in its true form - as is. I have used this for self-analysis which great results, and it really provides a sense that everything fits in and that it isn't quite so fragmented. It also helps to understand God, who is infinite. Science is perhaps the biggest label we give to all the tangible-truth-based philosophies we have today. Science is, logically, 100% wrong. However, that's not /quite/ true because the things possible in science are allowed to be possible by the laws of nature, and hense although science could be any colour of the rainbow it tends to match /usually/ with the colour of the truth. Thus we've almost found this so called unified theory within it. It is still false, however, because it is unwhole. The whole of life is a physics, not just the behaviour of matter. JC> ex. JC> Blagger1 > Waffle, waffle blah blah blah waffle waffle blah waffle. JC> Blagger2 > Huh, Oh yes, no thats not quite right because... Waffle JC> waffle. As above ;) JC> So what use is Philosophy ? Is it just an opportunity to let off steam JC> by blasting others belief systems apart with your very own, Not for me it isn't, but it does get fun now and then. JC> Is it a waste of time ? or better still, Is Philosophy a Philisophical JC> waste of time. <G>. Nothing is a waste of time. Without all the things of the past we wouldn't have arrived with the situation we're in now, and we consider this situation some kind of point of validity for asking what else is valid. It's a bit like people saying "if it weren't for such and such you wouldn't be here now". JC> argh, how am I doing. <g> not too good eh. Don't get me wrong though JC> I'm not trying to downside the subject... As if I could. <G>. I'm JC> doing a lot of grinning here arnt I. Nerves. Iv'e never followed JC> Philosophy before, and my only written Philosophy is from this Forum. JC> So I'm planning to get a simple Beginners Guide to philosophy this JC> week to see what it's really about. Well there are various `camps' and doctrines, which tend to conflict. People keep insisting on placing my infinite-based philosophy alongside theirs in comparison, except that that is contradictory. It's contradictory because infinity doesn't have a `side by side' ability, so you cannot make a comparison between it and anything else. This also tend to present self-righteousness, because infinity is self-evidently the truth. JC> Maybe you have a good explanation... pray do share... see you then, JC> Jeff. As above. Well anyway welcome to the echo. I've not been here long either. Nor do I like being called a philosopher. I do not feel that identity so I am not it. I don't think many people feel that they are one thing or another but are forced to express themselves as such. I'm not here for the saking of being philosophical, but rather I have my philosphy and I am injecting it here to brush away some of the cobwebs which unwhole philosophies propogate. I don't feel any kind of arrogance or whatever in doing this because there is just no question of what I'm saying being false. I suppose you could call it faith. Regards, Paul. Fidonet 2:251/31.8 PsychoNet 1080:108/0.4 IncarNet 153:250/8.4 --- * Origin: Delirious BBS, Hants. (2:251/31.8)