From Alex Macphee · 1996-04-02 04:30 · #76368 in APRIL
Hello Gregory, [Gregory Marsh to James Pharaoh, Mar 28 '96] GM> How about a revised version: 'every human act can be linked to selfish GM> reasons'. After all, our selfish genes prevent our doing GM> anything which we believe would endanger our survival, The problem with a proposition like this is that it is essentially untestable, because it can be applied, via post-hoc reasoning, to absolutely any situation you care to mention. In other words, you cannot distinguish between an altruistic act and a selfish act. The label X only has meaning if there are things that are not-X. However, taking the proposition at face value, what would be the gene survival value for a person's 'selfish genes' in endangering his own life to save that of a perfect stranger? GM> and out entire world model is built upon the premise that GM> out genes must survive. I think our world model is much older than our genetic model! -Alex --- MsgPost 1.1 * Origin: Voyager (01483 751324) (2:440/31)