From Tony Rigby · 1996-03-30 14:54 · #76348 in APRIL
24-Mar-96 02:54:40, Ray Girvan wrote to Tony Rigby
Subject: ethical values
-=>> Quoting Tony Rigby to David Jones <=-
RG> Hi, Tony,
RG> One, I think it's very iffy to get into
RG> arguing the qualities of something from the name it has.
RG> Parties choose names for the image they want to convey:
RG> for instance, the old German Democratic Republic, which
RG> was Communist. Stick to what political philosophies *do*
RG> rather than what they're called.
"By their fruits shall ye know them." If Fidel Castro says that he's a
socialist, then who am I to disbelieve him?
RG> Two: why don't you consider capitalism an ideology?
RG> Free-market capitalism, for instance, seems quite
RG> prescriptive to me; it has definite rules on how particular
RG> situations should be dealt with.
Well, there's plenty of capitalist literature in which authors espouse
various strands or varieties of capitalism, that's for sure. What I
mean here is that capitalism is essentially empirical: the writings
come AFTER the practise. With socialism the reverse is true: the
practise proceeds FROM the theory.
TR>> Oh, and neither do I accept that socialism ... was a
TR>> "well-intentioned idea".
RG> Not even as an understandable reaction to social systems where
RG> a large number of people were poor, and supporting a small
RG> incredibly rich elite class? I think the idea of an
RG> ultra-egalitarian system would seem very tempting to
RG> would-be reformers under those circumstances. Look at the
RG> pre-revolutionary systems in countries where Communism caught
RG> on.
But look, too, at what the reformers actually did. The Tsars, for
example, practised internal exile, but the Gulag system was a Soviet
invention. "By their fruits..." again, I'd say.
RG> (It's also interesting to compare these with pre-revolutionary
RG> France, and England before the Civil War; again, situations
RG> where a rich elite vs poor underclass polarisation broke down
RG> to be replaced by a system with a rabidly anti-elitist basis).
Are you sure? I don't think either of those events did much for the
poor. They were class conflicts, for sure, but the poor were not one of
the MAIN contenders in either, I would have thought. BTW, do you think
there are useful comparisons to be made between England under the
Commonwealth and Iran under the Ayatollahs? An interesting thought, at
any rate, and probably one worth researching a bit.
Bye... T.
--- Terminate 3.00/Pro
* Origin: One of Susy's better points (2:254/288.4)