Slimelite BBS

Manga

Back to HERBS-N-SUCH

From Paul Hallam · 1996-04-11 07:35 · #76278 in HERBS-N-SUCH

Hi Fox.
 
  -= Quoting you from Feb 10th 'cause I didn't answer :) =-
  PH>> Xenon - The Heavy Metal Warrior #1 I must admit I found this
  Ft> I found the ultimate ending unsatisfying, rather a standoff
  Ft> like Mai the Psychic Girl, rather than a solid good guys
  Ft> win, bad guys lie around the floor in small gooey pieces...
It tends to be a feature of Jap stuff that they tend to have less
good guy/bad guy and more grey areas. I wonder if this is not something
to do with their ying/yang ideas? (Or whether I am completely off the 
track.)
 
  PH>> Battle Angel Alita An excellent read. I was suprised that it
  PH>> was a lot more bloodthirsty 
  Ft> It does go on rather though. The current volume seems to be
  Ft> picking up a bit, but I found the whole Rollerball thing a
  Ft> big digression
I am currently working my way through the graphic novels.
A mate of mine watched the Anime and his comment was that the first
half was a 'different kind of story' from the second. He seemed to think
the second half was more predicatable etc...
 
  PH>> Barefoot Gen : A Cartoon Story Of Hiroshima
  Ft> Never read it. Largely because I suspected that this would
  Ft> be my reaction.  I gather there are like 4 volumes of it. 
Hmmm... I do not think I could stomach any further vols. :(
 
  PH>> Outlanders #3 and #4 What can I say?
  Ft> I have seen 1. on occasion, but the print run on 2 must have
  Ft> been microscopic; I mean, I was there waiting for it when it
  Ft> was published but never saw it.
I am glad they re-issued Trade P #1 and #2. :)
Kahm is much more scary than I had guessed from #3 and #4 alone.
When do the next lot (#5) appear?
 
BTW When Kham is figthing the Earth soldiers she slices the head of one
in half - and then the next scene is Tetsuya watching in horror as the alien 
woman holds aloft the head of a man *which is in one piece*. Eh!?!
That is what comes of calling your studio after a Ramen recepie - you lose 
all your noodles!
 
  PH>> Anyone rate Striker, Sanctuary, Harbour View, Pineapple
  PH>> Army, Hell Baby, or  3*3 Eyes? 
Pineapple army is well cool. :)
 
  Ft> ^^^^^^^^^ Haven't read the others but 3*3 Eyes has been a
  Ft> fave since way before the american edition appeared.  Art is
  Ft> way better than the anime. Interestingly, I picked up the
  Ft> japanese vol. 1 shortly before the american collected
  Ft> edition came out.
  Ft> It also had more nipples. 
Eh? :))))
 
<Moaning and whinging crunched> 
  Ft> Yes, but that is because they were intended for a format
  Ft> which is a lot cheaper. since a japanese weekly comic might
  Ft> expect to sell 5 MILLION copies, the unit price is not much
  Ft> more than nothing, particularly since the weeklies are
  Ft> printed on bog paper. They are also several hundred pages
  Ft> thick, with maybe a dozen strips running - kind of like the
  Ft> old style british comics but on a grand scale  Wheras the
  Ft> american edition prints maybe 20,000 and then uses expensive
  Ft> paper at that.
How about a British edition? Or are we *way* too small?
 
  Ft> It does seem like the cheapest and most
  Ft> efficient way to read manga is to order original collections
  Ft> from Books Nippon or the Japan Centre  and learn to read
  Ft> kana. 
Heh heh Heh. Sounds like an ad for Japan_UK. :)
 
  PH>> 'Trade Paperbacks' rule, single-ish comics suck.
  Ft> Trouble is, what about the absolutely incredible strips that
  Ft> nobody else recognises the value of that are never reprinted
  Ft> as TP?  It's russian roulette. 
I tend to like *everything* so I am okay as I will miss loads anyway since I 
only have a finite amount to spend on Manga. :)
 
I have now read "Hotel Harbour View"
Hmmm....
 
Mata Ne,
Paul.
--- ARCbbs RISC OS [1.64á32c]
 * Origin: Digital Databank BBS (01707) 323531 (2:257/501)