From Simon Harmel · 1996-04-13 21:14 · #76198 in ISDN
I had to forward this post from the internet...it's a good read...
=============================================================================
* Forwarded by Simon Harmel (2:440/222)
* Area : REC.AUTOS.SPORT.F1 (REC.AUTOS.SPORT.F1)
* From : gregoryd@sirius.com (Gregory Descho, 2:254/281 (10 Apr 96 12:30)
* To :
* Subj : Another long/interesting post = Refueling
=============================================================================
Newsgroups: rec.autos.sport.f1
Subject: Another long/interesting post = Refueling
Date: Wed, 10 Apr 1996 12:30:03 -0800
Organization: Sirius Connections
Lines: 154
Message-ID: <gregoryd-1004961230030001@ppp113-sf1.sirius.com>
NNTP-Posting-Host: ppp113-sf1.sirius.com
Refueling strategy : Food for thought
This is a translation of an article published in a French magazine (F1
1996 championship Guide).
This particular article is about refueling strategy at benetton and I
thought it was very interesting. Most topics in this magazine come with
comments fron J. Alesi (which is why I decided to share ;- )
As usual, the [..] are from me, and the translation is NOT guaranteed etc
etc+. Also, I the calculations MAY not be 100 % correct+don't bother
telling me about that, it's just an example anyway...
Here goes :
Put yourself in Ross Brown shoes (tech director at Benetton). You must
plan your refueling strategy for Jean Alesi and Gerhard Berger for a 300
Km GP, run on 60 laps. You have calculated that you will need 210 liters
of fuel to cover the distance, and you know that an excess of 17 liters
of fuel (13 kg) will make you lose 5 tenths of a second each lap due to
the extra weight alone. Let's say you decide that Alesi will stop 3 times
to refuel. His race will really be 4 distincts runs of 15 laps and 75 km
each, and he will carry 52.5 liters of fuel (40 kg) at the start of the
race, but also at the 15 th, 30 th and 45th lap. You estimate that each
of the pit stops - including getting to and from the pits - will cost you
20 seconds, so 60 seconds for all 3 stops. Now, for Berger, you are
planing 2 stops only, therefore a race divided into 3 runs of 20 laps and
100 Km each. He will carry 70 liters of fuel (53 kg) at the start and
also at the 20th and 40 th lap.
[Follow me so far ?]
Now, due to the extra 18 liters or so of fuel that will need to flow from
the pits to the fuel tank of Gerhard's car, each of his stops will last
at least a second longer that those of Alesi. Berger will therefore
spend 42 seconds in the pits.
Alesi will have to compensate on the track this 18 seconds handicap by
the extra speed that his lighter fuel load will give to his car. [Now it
gets interesting]
Up to the 15th lap, Alesi will be 13 Kg lighter than berger and will
therefore be 7.5 seconds [potentially] faster than his teammate. From the
15th top the 20th lap, he will be 27 Kg heavier and will lose 5.5
seconds. From the 20th to the 30th lap, he will be 27 Kg lighter and will
save 11 seconds. From the 30th to the 40 th lap, he will lose 5 seconds
from the 13 kg weight penalty. From the 40th to the 45th lap, he will
weight 40 Kg less and should save 7.7 seconds.
Total of the gains: 7.5+11+7.7=26.2
Total of the losses: 5.5+5+18 of extra pit time = 28.5 (18=60-42)
At this stage of the race, there are 15 laps to go. Alesi is 2.3 seconds
behind berger, they have the same fuel quantity but jean has fresher tires.
[Please don't go nitpicking about the calculations. Also, this is weight
only, not actual racing conditions with other people on the track]
This simple analysis is confusing, you don't really know which strategy
is the best anymore. And this just took into account the weight factor.
This weight will have an impact on tire wear, especially for berger's
heavier car. This will also impact fuel consumption. Berger will drive a
heavier car, and therefore may have a poorer gas mileage and need to
spend some extra seconds adding up a little more fuel than expected.
Each of the drivers also drives in his own style with a different setup,
also having an impact on fuel consumption, weight and tire wear. How
many sets of good tires do you have available after practise and
qualifying ? Also, by adding an extra pit stop for Jean Alesi, you
increase the chance of a screw up (stall, bad bolt, traffic in the pit
lane, one set of tires of lesser quality).
You will most likely need to adapt that strategy according to what is
happening on the race track. Pit earlier or later to take advantage of a
set of clear laps, pass another competitor, plan for an extra pit stop or
one less, if you have enough fuel to make it... [here, your strategy just
went out the window!]
Last year, the best demonstration of Benetton's superior pit stop
strategy was the GP of Hungary, but it went unnoticed. The refueling
machine for Schumacher broke, so he was sent back to the track for a few
laps, in order to reset Herbert's machine and to manage both cars' race
with a single refueling machine !
[snipped]
Says Flavio Briatore : "Our best time in the pits in training (without
refueling, just 4 tires), is 3.2 seconds ! Every wedneday, we practise
for 3 hours. In a race, we think the operation is a success if we stay
below 4 seconds (factoring stress, curbersome equipment etc+). Check out
our mechanics, they are the only ones to be kneeled on the floor before
the car has come to a complete stop. If the pilot stops 20 centimeters
short or long, it all goes to hell."
Says Jean : A moment of anxiety
"For or against ? We all like or dislike pit stops according to the car
we drive and our specific advantages.
[as in+. I loved them with last year's thirsty ferrari !] The pits stops
have changed GP racing and they need to be factored in your strategy.
Since Verstappen's accident (the benetton on fire in the pits) at the
German GP, I admit to being worried every time. You arrive at high speed
in a pit lane full of mechanics, tires, tools, hoses, and try to stop
the car at a precise spot to facilitate the mechanics' work and be in the
same situation they practised in+ Fuel transfer, tire replacement, Go
signal..so many thing out of our control ! and all likely to fall under
Murphy's law. A drop of gas on a burning exhaust pipe, an valve stuck
open, [ which BTW is what happened to Diniz car in argentina, dixit
RPM2..fuel valve stuck open], a wheel bolt not tight enough, a hand sign
misinterpreted+..
The rule ? Stay calm and keep your eyes at the same time on the mirrors
and on the person that supervises the operations"
Other interesting pieces of jean's opinion on several topics/articles :
Hand clutch and left foot braking :
"The hand clutch is a very helpful piece of equipment for starts, but it
becomes annoying when you spin. In that case, the best reflex is to jam
your foot on the clutch , to turn the wheel into the slide, block the
brakes and rev your engine to the max. With a hand clutch, you end up
with both feet on the brakes!
Left foot braking ? BULLSHIT ! It is not because Mika, like a lot of
scandinavian drivers has learned to drive that way that you have to force
it on everyone like it is the fashion nowadays. I often heard Schumacher
say that he was braking with the left foot, so this year, I asked his
engineers, and they told me it wasn't true." [Schumi, master of
tricks ? ;-) ]
Setup
"Oversteering or understeering car ? The theory says a slight understeer
that you can stop by lifting the foot off the throttle is better. It
allows for a better feel of the limits of the car at the edge and gives
you a safer feel. Personally, I prefer a more lively car, because I like
to pilot on the front axle. Oversteer does not bother me one bit, I
master it with the throttle. Understeer bothers me, I hate a car that is
lazy in its steering changes, because the first part of a turn is the
most important one. It is the one that prepares the exit and allows you
to have your car lined up the soonest to reaccelerate earlier."
Start / False start system
"I put my front wheels as close as possible to the painted line. 1st gear
in, one foot on the brakes to avoid all glitch of the clutch that could
make the car lurch forward and give a false start reading. [ BTW, the
target under the car painted by the photo cell is 30 centimeters long ,
so if you position your car -and the target attached to it - at the front
or back edge of the cell, you may have 0 cm or 30 of allowed movement
before a false start is registered ! If you're smack in the center -
lucky you - 15 centimeters each way. Also, you may spin your wheel for 2
seconds before the start, but if the car doesn't move more than the
above, you're fine! ] This system is very precise and almost perfect,
because lots of pilots didn't hesitate to steal starts before. But it
does require great care in cases of a slope on the start finish line,
like in Spa or Suzuka.
That's all folks..hope you enjoyed it and are a little more informed !
Greg.
-+-
+ Origin: Locomotion BBS - The Best In Formula 1 - 0181-224-8228 (2:254/281)
=============================================================================
Internet newsgroups are available from Explosion BBS..number below..
________ _________________
(_ |_|
|____)imon | |armel - SYSOP of Explosion BBS - 01732 773369
... Umm...your ZIP is open...
--- GoldED 2.50 UNREG
* Origin: Explosion BBS - 01732 773369 - FREE Email/Usenet! (2:440/222)