Slimelite BBS

'doze "FileManager" is crap.

Back to DEMOCRACY

From Richard Murray · 1996-03-29 23:03 · #75613 in DEMOCRACY

Quoting Paul Nott (in MCIBTYC)...

PN> Its not a hardware/interface problem, its an Operating System problem.
Exactly.

PN> This is not a fault of FileManager, its a fault of the standard DOS file-
PN> system which does not support multiple access modes.
'doze hacks a lot of DOS. Why not this too? You'll notice that the DOS
installation code is different before 'doze and after 'doze.

What about the old concurrent DOS? That suggests a possible ability to do
multiple operations?

PN> Most PC's are still using the filesystem developed by Microsoft 14 years
PN> ago, very few are using NTFS or HPFS which *do* allow multiple access.
Some people say the Acorn FilerAction gizmo is a big hack to implement
pseudo-multiple operations. I cannot say for sure as I've not seen any
sources. However it works...

Just one of the ways RiscOS is better than 'doze. ;^)

PN> Theres nothing wrong with IDE if you use it on a decent architecture - ie
PN> not on a PC.
I find IDE slower, but heck - anything is better than floppies. :-) Besides,
this is reflected in IDE prices. It's just a shame you can't chain a whole
heap of drives together. I have two IDE drives and nowhere to put a CD-ROM. Ah
well... Guess it'll be a SCSI one.

PN> Amigas have been doing this since 1985 with a 7.14mhz 68000.
I know. A friend had about three harddiscs and four floppies on an A500 and
then verified them all at the same time. Good grief, hear the noise. It
sounded a bit like the old MS-DOS 2.xx booting. But hey - it worked.

PN> old 1985 Amigas can still do DOS operations that todays state of the art
PN> PC's cannot do.
Processor has nothing much to do with disc operations really. Look at SCSI. A
command is sent to the disc which figures it out with itself. Some systems
don't even use the CPU for disc ops -- just like the Acorns don't need the CPU
to read out the screen memory.

PN> SCSI has not really taken off widely on the PC, the reason being is under
PN> the DOS environment (inc. Windows)  you can not transfer more than 64k
PN> via DMA.  So if you want to shift 14mb over SCSI, you have to tell the
PN> bus to transfer 64k 224 times.
Hmmm... Older Acorns had something like a 4K podule (expansion card)
addressing limitation. Even so, I've obtained a steady 2.2Mb/sec transfer rate
in various screen modes. There must be something fundamentally ***ked with DOS
if a wonderful (!) PC can't do that speed in 64K.

Maybe SCSI was too difficult for the average PCer to fit? <giggle>

PN>RM> If the "sadly deluded" Acorn system used by "dorks" (re: Sunday Times)
PN>RM> can manage it, then surely that pathetic mess known as "industry
PN>RM> standard" can manage it.
PN> Not in my lifetime it won't!
True.

On comp.sys.acorn.advocacy I saw a message to the effect of:
--8<--------
What "industry standard"? I've seen no "industry standard". Where can I get a
copy?
--8<--------

Says all you need to know really.

   ___
  /__/
 /  \ichard.

PS: Footnote for anybody here thinking Amigas are crap games machines. I have
    recently dug up a press release from some 10-odd years ago selling the
    Amiga system as a desktop/office machine.
    Makes you wonder why you'd need custom graphics/sound hardware for a
    spreadsheet. Anyhow, whoever put in that hardware should be congratulated.
    The Amiga may be weird (HAM/halfbright displays?) but it certainly had
    great graphics for it's day. I wonder what the new PowerAmiga (?) will
    offer -- and how long it'll take Acorn to better it. <vbg>
--- 8 out of 10 BSE-infected cows say '!ooooooooM'.
 * Origin: Worrying Heights [Encina] (2:254/86.1)