Slimelite BBS

poll

Back to IMAGINE

From Trevor Wallace · 1996-04-06 08:38 · #74992 in IMAGINE

G'day Wilbur!

"poll", Wilbur Hooks bellowed to All...

 WH> I thought since it's been awhile since one was done,

fairy snuff, it's a (mostly) free world :> And `tis not something I've ever done before, answering one o' these things, for reasons ye'll no doubt discover... ;>

 WH> Here's the questions:

Ye're expecting nice, simple, single answers, aren't ye? heh.

 WH> 3. Who is your favorite villain?

The Master, all of them. Even if his chronological encounters with the Doctor are rather implausible, and he might've lost his way a little toward the end (even if I haven't yet seen his last few performances - bugger!), overall I reckon his character's fared better than most of the recurring bad guys...

Plus, I just dig his general appearance. Assassin and Traken excepted, BOC :>

 WH> 4. "   "   "     "      producer?

Producer? Yikes, about the only one I can recall besides JNT, who I loathed, was the first one, and well, no I can't even manage that. I do recall saying though, quite early in his reign, that I thought JNT would be the end of Who.

If he had've bowed out at the same time Davison did, I think I'd regard him one hell of a lot better. Up until Caves of Androzani, I think Who was better than it had ever been, for the most part...

 WH> 5. "   "   "     "      director?
 WH> 6. "   "   "     "      script editor?
 WH> 7. "   "   "     "      writer?

Not being a writer or a director, I'm in no position to rate these things, even if I do have ideas as to what I particularly like. For all I know, I prefer shows with bangs n' body counts, artistic values be damned.

Best ask someone who considers such things... :>

 WH> 10. "   "   "   "        reference book for Dr. Who?

The twentieth anniversary one, it's title eludes me at the moment. Nice pictures, write ups on all the stories and the bad guys, and good guys, along with instructions on how to build ye own time machine. :>

The twenty first was good as well, with a day by day account of the making o' the series, but I don't recall being quite so wrapped with it.

The Tech Manual is pretty spack, although I loved it when I first laid hands on it, aged about twelve at the time. :>

 WH> 11. "   "   "   "   Hartnell episode?

`tis hard to say, not knowing whether my memories come from screen or print. The Myth Makers was a neat book, but I don't even know if it exists. The Romans was the last one I saw...

 WH> 12. "   "   "   "   Troughton episode?

See above. I liked what I've seen o' The Moonbase, can't remember if `tis all available, but I'd really like to see The Web Of Fear, the first ever Who novel I read...

 WH> 13. "   "   "   "   Pertwee episode?

ahhh, getting onto more familiar ground now. :>

I have rather positive recollections of The Mutants and The Green Death, so I'll call those...

 WH> 14. "   "   "   "  T. Baker episode?

sheesh. Most of the first season, Deadly Assassin, Face Of Evil, The Talons Of Weng Chiang, State Of Decay and Logopolis. Take ye pick. If I have to name just one, possibly Genesis Of The Daleks...

 WH> 15. "   "   "   "  Davison episode?

oh oh. The Programme Guide stops at the end of Baker's reign, so no more prodding the brain cells with print... :|

Most of the first season, perhaps excepting Timeflight and Four To Doomsday. The guardian trilogy and all of season twenty except The Awakening. Again, if I have to name just one, I probably say Black Orchid.

 WH> 16. "   "   "   "  C. Baker episode?

This is unfortunately easy. Twin Dilemma, a promising start, I thought, but soon after I lost track of the entire thing. I might've grown up for a bit there...

 WH> 17. "   "   "   "  McCoy episode?

I've not seen enough to really comment, perhaps Silver Nemesis was good, but Delta and the ranks as perhaps the worst ever...

 WH> 18. Who is your least favorite companion?

Hard to say. comes across, to me, as a bit of a prat, but I kind of liked him at the time. I didn't think much of Ace when she joined the Doctor, but I didn't find her too bad with further viewing. Peri was irksome, but had nice titties, so I'll let her off.

I guess I'd prolly give my Crappiest Companion Logie to Sarah Jane Smith, supposedly a stronger female character, I didn't mind her so much at the time, but with hindsight I reckon she whinges too much.

 WH> 19. Which Doctor had the best outfit?

If I could have a coat like Colin Baker's, it be almost enough to get to wear something other than black. Overall though, I'd say I was most taken by Tom Baker's final season attire, the burgundy get up.

 WH> 20. Which lost story would you most lie to be found in its entirety?

All of them, n' if they are absolutely beyond saving, they should be reconstructed. Sooner or later, digital technology should allow faithful reproductions of human actors long gone, and I reckon it'd be splish if the long gone Who eps were to be recreated...

A nice fantasy, no?

 WH> 1. Who is your favorite Doctor?

ummm, a toughie. Tom Baker's an easy choice, he ran with role for so long, and had such an impact on the show, to the point where I've even picked up a few of his mannerisms.

Davison's Doctor has what I consider to be the best time of it, with good stories and decent production values on the whole, and he was a likable enough character (although aren't they all?) and I was greatly disappointed when he left...

I also enjoy Troughton's spin on the character, and I think he had good material to work with, but overall, I guess I'll be dull n' boring and pick Tom Baker as my all time fave...

 WH> 2. Who is your favorite companion?

Even harder, because there's more of the buggers. Having got the least favourite out of the way first, I can narrow it down to a choice of two, I guess - Jamie and Leela.

More than a couple of comparisons there, I think. Both characters were backwards and somewhat barbaric, easily allowing the Doctor to both educate and preach at them, which I suppose is the role of the companion. Unlike Harry Sullivan, who was backward, barbaric and a prat; better stick him up in the least popular category! :>

Back to Leela and Jamie, I think the actors made the characters seem well likable too, and they both looked good in short skirts. `nuff said. :>

Overall, though - Leela. She looked better. And tended to kill indiscriminately. :>


And now I'm sure ye understand why I don't normally respond to such surveys - I can't give a straight answer. :>

have fun
    "...on Earth it is considered  ill-mannered to
    kill your friends while committing suicide."
                                       - swaz

--- FMail/386 1.02
 * Origin: CVE Rentals - Competitive Daily Rates! (3:800/447)