From Sandman · 1996-04-04 03:07 · #74934 in IMAGINE
In reply to Some reading at last! by Earl Green
Regarding your impression of the Davison Doctor Who Handbook, I was surprised that you seemed to feel negatively toward it. I myself was very impressed with it, the authors having produced the book with their usual skill. It sounds as if you have a particular fondness for the Fifth Doctor's era, and so do I. However, rereading the handbook, I found myself nodding in agreement with what they had to say. Frankly, I think that the authors were right to point out that there was some serious concern that style was winning out over substance. IMO, for every Castrovalva, Kinda, and Earthshock (it's pretty shallow and showy, but I still like it), you have Four to Doomsday, Time-Flight, and Arc of Infinity. The Caves of Androzani is so superior to any single other Davison adventure that it's amazing it was produced by the same man who crowed at how wonderful The Twin Dilemma was! I look back on the Davison era, and I see a lot of opportunites wasted. Arc of Infinity and Warriors of the Deep cheapen the memory of the great stories they were inspired by. Snakedance is another superior story that really has the look of only accidentally being well produced. Judging the Davison era as a whole, it was IMO mediocre, with only occasionaly flashes of high consistent quality. Unlike the first three years of Tom Baker, for example. I defy anyone to find a clunker in all three seasons (well, except for Revenge of the Cybermen). One story in 17 was a dud. Of Davison's three seasons, only a handful are quality, far more merely average, and one or two are dire (hello, Four to Doomsday, and Warriors) I don't mean to slag off on Davison. Actually, I am fond of his Doctor, I just am frustrated that his era didn't create more memorable stories. BTW, regarding your new NA/MA purchases: The Empire of Glass is terrific, and so is The Also People (just finised reading that one. Don't let the fact that Ben (Transit) Aaronovitch wrote it put you off. It's a real good read). Cheers! Sandman/Doug Campbell --- Opus-CBCS 1.73a * Origin: The Personals-MemTN-Unbuckling the Bible Belt<tm> (1:123/22.0)