From Wilbur Hooks · 1996-04-03 05:47 · #74932 in IMAGINE
PG>Then that's why he didn't destroy them? PG>It would have created a paradox. I still think it was on moral grounds, and besides, he had still created the paradox. If we accept Cornell's explanation, then the events which led to this story didn't take place. It's like coming to a spot on a river where the branch your on and another branch converge into a larger river. A landslide occurs and cuts off the branch you just traveled down. As a result the part of river your now in more shallow than the last time you were here. The branch you traveled down is no longer part of this larger river. However, you still traveled down it. You should here PG> WH> his explanation for the 2nd Doctor in regards to The Three, Five, PG> WH> and Two Doctors stories 8-). PG>Why, is it a laugh?? ;) No, but in some ways it's as complicated as the problem itself. Here it goes: The Doctor was not immediatley exiled and forced to regenerate as we saw on screen. Instead, the CIA intervened and gave him his freedom at a price. He had now become their errand boy. In The Two Doctor's the Time Lords appear to have dual control over the Tardis and are monitoring his every move. One of the benefits of the relationship is the Stattenhiem Remote Control. He also note how here and in the Five Doctors the 2Doctor looks much older. He believes this was when the secondary control room was used, because the 4Doctor said he used to never be able to control where it landed. Cornell also cites that the planned landings in the Five Doctors and Two Doctors were far above the abilities of the 2Doctor. The Time Lords decided he worked best with companions so allowed him to pick up Jamie and Victoria somewhere between the Five Doctors and the Two Doctors, as in the latter Jamie is with him and he mentions with some confidence being able to pick Victoria up from where he dropped her off. Finally, the 2Doctor gets fed up and possibly removes the device that give the Time Lords dual control. They catch up with him and finally enforce the sentence seen in War Games. PG>Are there any books that I should pick up? The Lofficier trilogy is rather good, though by the time I got it I didn't need the Program Guide. However, the Universal Databank is the best "who encyclopedia" I've seen and the Terrestial Index is great for the times when you're puzzled why Murgrave (Castrovalva) and Prof. Litefoot (Talons of Wneg-Chiang) look so muck alike. The Dicontinuity Guide: A good attempt to resolve and celebrate the show's discrepancies. Each section is broken up as follows: Roots: Possible influences on stories. A bit overdone. It can make you think none of the scriptwriters had an idea that was their own. Goofs: Miscues, offscene-onscreen antics, misused or ill-timed props, and historical innaccuracies. Makes you much more observant during the episodes. On any given story I might a notice a third of the ones' he lists. Fluffs: Verbal bloopers. These can be fun to watch for. However he's a little disgenerous to Hartnell and (like others) marks what I seemed to be part of his character (tetchy and somewhat flustered) up to an over-the-hill actor who lost the ability to remember lines. Double Entrendes: Statements which seperated from the action make you wonder what REALLY goes on in the TARDIS. Dialougue Disasters: The ones that make you cringe. Once again Cornell gets a little disgenerous as some of these work within the context of the onscreen action. Dialougue Triumphs: The ones that make you weep. Unfortunately, some of the best are a little long and Cornell occasionally paraphrases. Technobabble: The megabyte modem. Need I say more. Continuity: Cornell does a wonderful job connecting points and pointing out events no matter how insignificant in the show's stories. His theories are well thought out and he offers them as possibilities not law. However, the more thorny the problem, the more convoluted the theory. He is very open-minded and in the foreword encourages everyone to accept what they like and invent for themsleves what they don't. Location: Where and when the story takes place. Untelevised Adventures: References to events not broadcast. (i.e. the terrible Zodan) Bottom Line: What Cornell and his collaborators thought of the overall story. Sometimes I agree with them spot on, others I have a bone to pick. Such is life.... * SLMR 2.1 * "Two suits is dead!"-Cat --- Renegade v10-05 Exp * Origin: Miskationic University, Nashville, TN(615)262-2773 (1:116/78)