From Peter Goddard · 1996-04-06 02:37 · #74905 in IMAGINE
SW> For example which Doctor agreed, quite freely, to be interviewed in
SW> the recent video `More Than Thirty Years In the TARDIS' and waxed
SW> lyrical and lovingly about it, McCoy or Tom Baker? Answer... McCoy!
DJ> I haven't seen the video but I'll take your word for it.
I think that everyone just takes it all so seriously.
OK it's a TV programme and we enjoy certain stories - why should you be
made to feel any less about yourself just because of personal taste.
It is a lark just like fido and anyone who takes either too seriously
should really take a look at the state of themselves.
I liked five of the Doctors. The last two were a little crap in their
stories.
Well very crap. There were good moments but they were few and far
between.
I don't see why a fan of a programme should be told that they aren't one
just because they take every little word that is uttered as gospel.
If something sucks I won't make an excuse - why should I?
I'm not about to march down the street chanting "Heil Doktor!" at the
top of my voice for anyone, least of all the BBC.
DJ> Okay. I don't have a problem with Peter being open and honest.
<Sigh!> If anyone does then I suggest a cold shower. ;)
DJ> Do you think he takes pleasure in looking back at some of his past
DJ> work and saying it was a load of crap? Probably not.
Why the hell not? He's probably not a fan!
It was a job.
DJ> I'd much rather have Tom Baker, someone who actually contributed
DJ> to the success of Dr Who, hold the record than Sylvester McCoy
DJ> who says nice things about the program and the fans but was a
DJ> dissapointment onscreen when it mattered the most.
There were Baker stories that stank to high heaven as well.
Round about all of the key to time season was utter crap. Cliched
dribbling rubbish, dull boring and monotonous.
DJ> Steve, your reading too much into what I said. You were
DJ> comparing Sylvester McCoy to Tom Baker and I responded likewise.
DJ> I wasn't on a pro-Tom Baker rant if that's what you thought.
There is such a thing as free speech.
As long as you simp around the (beautiful, charming and friendly)
moderator then theoretically as long as no real harrasment or explicit
language is being used you should be allowed to say what you like about
the underlined topic.
Rant if you want to, don't mind me.
DJ> I've recorded every Dr Who story that remains intact
BTW, that excludes showing off.
Git. ;)))
SW> actually the same person!! He milked what had been (originally 13
SW> week, then 50 week, then 3 year) series into a six year series
SW> (all in black and white - twice the longevity of Star Trek which
SW> was `filmed' in colour!)
Yeah Steve, but the thing about Star-Trek, the very little basic
factette you have to consider when comparing voth seriess is very
simple.
Doctor Who is good and Star-Trek isn't.
I'd like to see the budget version of ST-TNG stand up with virtually
only a few hoover parts some tin-foil and string up against a flecked
black blanket.
Or maybe it might get good if forced into such restrictions? My guess
is that it would fall flat and become the Sci-Fi pantomime horse, the
kind a character kicks to get a cheap laugh.
If it ain't already.
DJ> I absolutely love Troughton's Doctor too! The stories that
DJ> still exist may not be considered classics but the dialogue between
DJ> the Doctor, Jamie and Zoe is absolutely hilarious.
I agree.
They should have pulled out all the stops to make more stories.
But at the time I suppose it was always just designed to last to the
next month.
After 30 odd years the excuse is wearig a little thin...
DJ> I know the story 'The Krotons' isn't liked by many but I enjoy
DJ> watching it just for the interaction between the regulars!
I suppose.
But the interaction between regulars kept many a crap story together.
DJ> I can't help but shake my head after watching those Troughton
DJ> episodes knowing that there are so many that I'll never get to
DJ> see.
You can never tell.
I never thought I'd see Tomb.
DJ> I enjoyed Pertwee's run. His stories were always a lot of fun
DJ> and you couldn't help but love Joe, Sarah, Brigadier and the Master.
The thing is that they were always very innovative for being a Sci-Fi
series that had run aground on Earth.
They didn't have aliens trying to invade every story either.
The Silurans - You can hardly call them alien as we are more alien than
them.
Inferno - The mutating humans and parallel universe.
Also others that got round the barrier like Colony and The 3 Docs.
DJ> Well, I'd say Tom was being just a little humble when he made
DJ> that statement. Taking on such an important role in a successful
DJ> program isn't as easy as that.
It's easier than you might think to find someone who will be right for
the role.
DJ> If it was that easy Doctor Who would never have left our screens.
It wasn't Syl that wrote his stories. He only acted in them.
DJ> In regards to your comment about "monsters, foes, enemies", just a
DJ> little reminder that the Baker era relied very little on the old
DJ> adversaries and was pretty original when it came to that aspect of
DJ> the show.
The early Baker creations were very good but later it was plainly
obvious that evryone was getting tired the format was getting jaded and
stale.
That's the beauty of regeneration.
You can chop and change.
DJ> Don't sell us Canadians short. While the fans over in England
DJ> were bemoaning the total lack of old Doctor Who episodes being aired
DJ> (this was before UK Gold and all those other satellite channels) those
DJ> of us in Canada were watching the entire run of Doctor Who from the
DJ> first Hartnell through to the final McCoy (loving every minute of it
DJ> too I might add)
All that prooves is that their are loads of rich people who like the
show.
DJ> Steve, I enjoyed all the Doctors with the exception of one and
DJ> I think it's safe to say that you know who the sole exception was. I
DJ> don't blame McCoy so much because I think he never should have been
DJ> cast as the Doctor in the first place. John Nathan Turner deserves
DJ> most, if not all, the blame for the failings of the McCoy era.
Well it prooves what happens when floor cleaners get above themselves.
;)
DJ> Entrenched in what?!? My standards?!? I disliked the McCoy
DJ> era because I thought it was, to quote Mr. Davison, a load of crap!
DJ> Are you saying that because of that I'm destined to deslike McGann? I
DJ> liked the previous six incarnations of the Doctor Steve, does that not
DJ> count for something?
In my book a fan is omeone who likes something about something.
They don't have to believe the sun shines from the backside of every
person involved.
Adonai
P.
--- Blue Wave/RA v2.12 [NR]
* Origin: Surrey Education Community On-Line 01932-883606 (2:440/33) (2:440/33)