From Steve Williams · 1996-04-02 13:54 · #74883 in IMAGINE
On 03-17-96 22:17, DAVID, you wrote to me re: McCoy's tenure... - DJ> Steve, I hope this message doesn't come across as being too strong or DJ> written in anger because it wasn't. It doesn't. DJ> I intended it as a friendly, if a little heated, debate. The very stuff that this echo is all about! Don't apologise, enjoy! You are amongst friends here. 8-) DJ> I have to say it's really nice to be able to exchange ideas and opinions DJ> with a fellow WHO fan all the way over in England. Which is the very reason that this international WHO echo was created in the first place! Don't forget that you can not only communicate all the way over here to England - you can also talk to such faraway places as Scotland, Ireland, Wales, Mainland Europe, Australia (sometimes) and even Africa (very occasionally!) SW> I don't accuse you of being contrary, not at all. It's your opinion SW> and your entitled to it. But I /would/ say that it seems a little SW> jaundiced and very ungracious view. McCoy has been a fine ambassador SW> for the series! DJ> I don't think I was being ungracious towards McCoy but rather DJ> only stating why I felt he doesn't deserve the record for longevity. Well obviously it depends upon the criteria you base the decision upon. Hartnell did the most episodes - so therefore he was the longest serving Doctor? Tom Baker did the longest active tenure - so therefore he was the longest serving Doctor? McCoy was the actor whose first appearance and the number of years before his final, official, BBC-sanctioned exit from the series, actually spanned the largest number of years - so therefore he was the longest serving Doctor? You pays your money, and you take your choice! SW> Finally, which Doctor, after being unceremoniously being /dumped/ SW> /on/ by the BBC refused to do the all important regeneration scene SW> for his successor, McCoy or Colin Baker? Answer... McCoy! DJ> Wrong! The answer is Colin Baker. Two out of three isn't a DJ> bad quiz result Steve but you really should score higher when you're DJ> the one writing the questions. ;) I was trying to be satirical by giving an obviously wrong answer. Obviously it didn't work out as I planned! DJ> Once again, I'd have to disagree. The show was cancelled during DJ> McCoy's run which lays a portion of the blame, however small, on DJ> his doorstep. Cancellation? What a lot of Rowlocks! (you can say that here, they're something you put your oars into - very appropriate!) Don't forget that the show was nearly cancelled many times - during Hartnell's, Troughton's, Pertwee's and Colin Baker's incumbencies! Blame the BBC scheduling, blame their finance department, blame JohnNathan Turner, blame the directors, blame the British viewing public, blame Colin Baker, blame Tom Baker for monopolising the part if you wish - BUT - don't blame McCoy for doing his best in a role that he was thrown into! `Time And The Rani' was indeed a shocker, but when you realise that it was written/adapted for C.Baker and not McCoy then his acting is forgivable! By the time McCoy reached `Delta And The Bannermen' he had the /role/ under control. After the departure of Mel, and the introduction of Ace, McCoy was as good as any of the other actors who've played the Doctor! DJ> I absolutely love Troughton's Doctor too! Are you trying to score points with the Q? My Fave too though! SW> Then Tom Baker came along and inherited the mantle. By this time SW> Doctor Who was `easy'. Even Tom Baker has even said in a recent SW> interview that it would take a total incompetent to `fail' in the SW> role he inherited... DJ> Well, I'd say Tom was being just a little humble when he made DJ> that statement. Taking on such an important role in a successful DJ> program isn't as easy as that. Well it was actually. Tom Baker was a failed priest and nearly a failed actor before the part landed in his lap. He was very lucky - Hartnell, Troughton, Pertwee, Davison, Colin Baker, even McCoy, were much `bigger' before they got offered the part of The Doctor! DJ> just a little reminder that the Baker era relied very little on the old DJ> adversaries and was pretty original when it came to that aspect of the DJ> show. Yup, I'll agree with that completely! I mean Tom Baker only met the Daleks (courtesy of William Hartnell) a few times, and I think he only met the Cybermen (courtesy of Patrick Troughton) a couple of times. Sontarans? Nahh forget them (courtesy of Jon Pertwee) they never crossed over at all! Finally, Of course we can completely ingore suggestion about The Master!!! DJ> I understand that Tom became difficult to work with at some DJ> point but at least give him credit for knowing when to hang up the DJ> hat and scarf (unlike a certain Doctor Who producer). Hehehehe.... you are quite right on that point!!! SW> One thing I have to keep reminding the younger (and more often or SW> not American and Canadian) users of this echo is that Doctor Who SW> did not start in 1974. 8-) DJ> Don't sell us Canadians short. Stop it right there bud!! Born in Guelph, Ontario, 12/13/54, I have a Canadian Birth Certificate, a Canadian Passport, and a British Passport. SW> So, if you are looking for heroes (or deserving cases) on which to SW> attach records then Tom Baker can get in the queue behind Hartnell, SW> Troughton and Pertwee. DJ> I'm not attempting to attach or create records for anyone but I would DJ> like to see some solid numbers and reasoning if someone else does. You may be a long-time waiting! DJ> (...who's not a big fan of the McCoy era.) ;) SW> Yup, well that's deeply sad because I think that you are so SW> obviously entrenched that you're no going to enjoy the McGann era SW> either!! DJ> Entrenched in what?!? My standards?!? Nope, traditions - most of them falsely based. Believe me, you won't like the New Who, I can tell you that now! The new series will somewhat irk the faithful - and that includes me. But at least I'm prepared for it!! Be Seeing You Steve. * AmyBW v2.13+ * ... If it breaks, it needed replacing anyway. --- Blue Wave/RA v2.13 AmyBW * Origin: Moon Moth :: fiawol or ijagh? :: 0181-777 9730 (2:254/222.0)