From Earl Green · 1996-03-29 08:59 · #74870 in IMAGINE
Hey there, hi there, ho there, Rob!
RA>It's been a while since I read "Love and War". In fact, it was one of the la
RA>NAs that I read. I found the Doctor's character to be going too far along th
RA>'manipulative' route, and it really put me off. I must admit that I don't
RA>recall any details of the plot, but he seemed just as devious in LAW as he
RA>did elsewhere. Have they improved since?
I've only seen a few of the post-Love and War NAs. The wonderful news
is that our local bookstore has finally gotten in a couple of new NAs,
a ton of MAs (of which I've seen none so far!) and the Davison
Handbook (ah, GLEE!). Naturally, I had 'em pull all of these off the
shelf and hold them for me!
RA>That is one of the reasons I quite like Battlefield - the story itself is no
RA>that marvelous, but the current Doctor isn't in control of the situation
RA>(even though his future self is!). We get a chance to see how McCoy's Doctor
RA>reacts to the unexpected, which in itself is something of a novelty.
I liked the 26th season, but many of the NAs I've seen have rather
ploddingly continued along the "manipulative Doc" track. It was fresh
and new and interesting and exciting and menacing in the first few TV
episodes in which it appeared; in fact, I initially liked it...though
it grew a bit old in the NAs I've read (though Love and War used it
very well and portrayed its potential lasting effects on everyone very
well - from Ace to the entire population of a hapless planet).
RA> EG> into the canon, I side with Paul - the seventh Doctor's "more than a
RA> EG> Time Lord" because he has taken it upon himself to be so, not because
RA> EG> of some unusual power conferred upon him.
RA>Yep, I think that's reasonable. After all, we know that Time Lords are highl
RA>intelligent, and as such should be capable of achieving any goals they care
RA>to set themselves. But why the sudden conversion from dealing with events as
RA>the arise, to setting up potential enemies and them picking them off at will
Probably trying to give the series an adult slant, which it certainly
did. Possibly also a comic-bookish slant as well - most of the
superheroes that seem to be around today come across to me as
vigilantes. And also likely to give the Doctor a "mad, bad, and
dangerous to know" quality. But there's no need for that basic plot
parameter to have taken over the whole concept of Doctor Who. As I
originally said, I liked the first few utilizations of the concept -
if the Doc was up against the Daleks, Cybermen or something like
Fenric, I could see his deviousness being a necessary weapon in his
arsenal. But manipulating Ace? Hmmmm. Interesting arguments there.
(That aside, I did like "Ghost Light" and "Survival," the latter of
which I'd wager was *not* so much of a "manipulation" plot as the
Doctor didn't initially realize the Master's involvement.)
RA>The Doctor seems to have changed from an explorer to a vigilante almost over
RA>night.
I'd never given that angle much thought - wow. You do point out a bit
of a deviation in the character of the Doctor, he said understatedly.
You give a guy a lot to think about, Rob! I'm not saying it's a bad
deviation - it was sure interesting, and will very likely go down as
the hallmark of Sylvester McCoy's era as the Doctor, just as whimsy
was Troughton's, dashing was Pertwee's, and insane was poor Colin's.
<G> (Don't get me wrong - I actually liked that about Colin!) But
it wasn't a basic parameter of the series as originally conceived.
(It could just as easily be argued that the Time Lords were similarly
not a part of the original concept...so much for my opinions!)
e <-- Earl Green (earl.green@3822-1.mx1.fidonet.org) 1:3822/1
Graphics/animation artist, KPBI Fox 46/15 & KFDF UPN 32/36
---
* SLMR 2.0 * He came 160 miles to wipe away all those smug smiles.
--- QScan/PCB v1.19b / 01-0162
* Origin: Jackalope Junction 501-785-5381 Ft Smith AR (1:3822/1)