From Chris Jackson · 1996-04-14 18:08 · #74416 in AMIGA_MAGS
Kirlian Photography
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
An amateur who is trying to carry out parapsychological experiments using
apparatus with which he or she may not be completely familiar is likely to
have to deal with many difficulties. A good example of this is provided by
Kirlian photography. Kirlian photography is supposed by many people to
produce a coloured picture of the aura or projecting portion of the etheric
body, some people perhaps referring to the same thing as the astral body.
(This is supposed to interpenetrate and project all around the physical
body, and to indicate by its colours the state of health, as well as the
emotional state.) Some Kirlian photographers give the most elaborate
diagnoses of the physical/emotional and mental states of a subject from an
inspection of the Kirlian photograph of a finger pad.
Kirlian photographs are obtained in the following way. For a finger-pad
photograph, a flat metal electrode has placed on it a colour film on to
which, in turn, is pressed a finger pad or a complete hand. A high
voltage, high frequency discharge is allowed to take place between the
electrode and the finger or hand, the latter being at earth potential. The
voltage is high enough to produce an electrical discharge between the
finger and the plate, but the frequency is sufficiently high to eliminate
discomfort felt by the subject. The photograph - which is not really a
photograph at all - is produced by the electrical discharge which results
from the high electric stresses in the air, producing ionization. The
colour of the discharge depends on gases and other chemicals present and
the electric stresses leading to the discharge depend on the curvature of
the surfaces. The current flowing through the three emulsion layers of the
film also decides features of the picture.
In another version of the process the discharge is caused to take place
between the high voltage electrode and an earthed plate electrode, a colour
film being placed between them, together with an object on the emulsion side
of the film.
Practitioners in this subject often suggest that the colours and brightness
of the photograph indicate such things as vibrant health, a dull
photograph indicating real of potential illness or disease. Dull
photographs are apparently sometimes changed to bright ones after a `healer'
has given the ailing subject healing treatment. In the second arrangement
described, if a leaf is used as the object then the practioners suggest
that the discharge from a living leaf is much brighter than the discharge
from a dead leaf, for the same reasons that led to a bright finger-pad
photograph - that there are ample quantities of `vital subtle forces'
flowing.
So how are the naive practitioners misleading themselvs and others? Is
there anything at all in these claims?
What decides the detail of the picture? These are determined by the flow
of current through the three emulsion layers of the film together with the
chemicals and gases (including mooisture) in the air surrounding the
Kirlian sandwich. Other features depend on the pressures between the
components of the sandwich. In the case of a finger, the finger pressure
determines the air spaces in which the discharges occur. Most importantly,
the nature of the voltage, its variations with time, and the frequency,
stability and the time of application of the voltage will all be of crucial
importance. Deductions made from Kirlian photographs are based on
comparisons between photographs. Thus a dull photograph before `healing'
followed by a bright one afterwards may be taken as evidence for the
efficacy of the healing. It should be quite clear that such comparisons
are invalid and meaningless unless all the other variables are carefully
controlled - and usually they are not. For example, finger presure is not
controlled and the high-voltage supply source is often a simple Tesla
circuit which electrical engineers well know to be erratic. There are
perhaps thirty different variables, the more important of which must be
controlled for valid comparisons of photographs.
There is a well-known picture of a leaf (taken with the second Kirlian
arrangement described) showing a discharge and a second picture taken with
a section of the leaf cut out. Features in the space where the leaf has
been removed are suggested as indicating the presence still of the `etheric
material'. In the case of the leaf picture, it seems highly likely that
the discharge in the space where the piece was cut out was probably due to
moisture and chemical substances left on the plate as a result of not
cleaning the electrodes properly. (A competant experimenter would have
given details in his or her paper of how the electrodes were cleaned. Such
details were significant by their absence.) The difference in the
brightness of discharge between that from a living leaf and that from a
dead leaf is merely due to the moisture present in the living leaf.
There is no real mystery about any of this to an electrical engineer who is
familiar with high-voltage discharges. To someone who is not familiar with
electrical engineering, or indeed with any physics at all, the electrical
discharge is just as mysterious as is the etheric body. Because the way
in which the etheric body appears to psychic `vision' around the surface of
a physical body is rather like the way an electrical discharge appears
around the surface of a discharging object, then a comparison is often drawn
between them.
I remember a lecture on Kirlian photography in which it was described how
two people who barely knew each other had placed their forefingers near
to each other on the Kirlian sandwich, a photograph being taken. Then two
people who were engaged to be married placed their fingers close together
in a similar way. The lecturer pointed out that the etheric material was
merging together in the case of the engaged couple! When I asked him
wether there were any other photographs of the discharges taken, both for
the two people who did not know each other and for the engaged couple, he
said that there were but he had selected the pair which showed the effect
best. Again it will readily be appreciated that the audience should have
been shown all the photographs and not only the two which showed what the
lecturer was suggesting. As he had no control over any of the numerous
variables no valid deductions of any kind could be drawn from the two
photographs shown.
Kirlian photography has been used for medical diagnosis. L.W.Konikiewicz,
an American researcher, used a stable oscillator to produce the
high-voltage supply and controlled all the independent variables. He used
an environmental chamber to maintain the humidity at a constant value and
he took special care to keep the film flat. He cleansed the fingers of his
subjects with distilled water, drying them in air and covering them with
cotton glove up to the moment of the test to prevent contamination. He
controlled the finger pressure carefully and the time of the discharge.
Using double-blind studies he correctly identificed with a high order of
accuracy cystic fibrosis patients and carriers of the gene.
Changes in Kirlian photographs (assuming all the independent variables to
be properly controlled) before and after healing should be expected as the
chemical constituents of the sweat on the skin will be altered. It is well
known that calmness and relaxation alone often alter these. This has
nothing to do with subtle bodies and subtle forces unknown to science.
Kirlian photography is potentially useful if all the important variables
are properly controlled and the work is undertaken by professionally
trained workers. Otherwise it provides yet another way by which the
ill-informed may deceive both themselves and their subjects.
One final remark - as psychokinesis somethimes genuinly takes place then it
might be possible for the electrical discharge of a Kirlian photograph to
be operated upon and modified by the minds of people such as healers, their
unconscious mind indicating to them appropriate diseases present by means
of such changes. This suggestion is similar to the explanation of the dark
patches seen by Kilner using his kilner screens. However, such events are
not likely to occur very frequently!
Something which is important - but which is almost always omitted from
descriptions of scientific experiments in parapsychology - is the mind of
the subject. Perhaps of equal importance, but similarly overlooked, are
the minds of the experimenters. If a subject achieves remarkably good
results in a telepathy experiment when using ganzfeld or equally good
results when trying to influence Jahn's electrical-pulse equipment, then it
is surely of great importance that the results should clearly describe
exactly what those successful subjects were doing with their minds. This
vital piece of information is almost always omitted from the reports.
Notes:
By using electrodes and a high-voltage high-frequency discharge, Kirlian
photographs are produced on colour film. Some people believe this gives an
impression of the etheric form and that the discharge from a living healthy
leaf is brighter than that from a dead leaf. However, it is difficult to
control all the variables and make valid comparisons.
Kirlian photographs use this sandwich arrangement. When an object such as
a leaf is to be photographed, it is placed between the upper (earthed)
plate and the film surface.
_
/| To earth
/
-----------^------ <- Metal plate
oooooo <------- Object
------------------ <- Film, emulsion side up
================== <- Insulation
-----------v------ <- Metal plate
\
\| To high voltage supply source
~
When a fingertip, hand or some other part of the body is photographed, no
upper electrode is required since the subject is, in normal conditions,
earthed. If the participant is not properly earthed however - perhaps
because he or she is wearing shoes with rubber soles, or is on a carpet
with a rubber underlay - there may be a loss of quality in the Kirlian
picture obtained.
oooooo <------- Object (hand)
------------------- <- Film, emulsion side up
=================== <- Insulation
------------v------ <- Metal plate
\
\| To high voltage supply source
~
Regards,
Paul.
Fidonet 2:251/30.15 SearchNet 114:3/0.4 PsychoNet 1080:108/0.4
Internet MrWest@15.Shining.Conqueror.Co.Uk Mercury 240:190/16.15
--- FMail/386 1.02
* Origin: >Demons Domain< (01642)724758 (2:256/604)