Slimelite BBS

What Science Believes

Back to AMIGA_MAGS

From Ian Muirhead · 1996-04-07 19:34 · #74264 in AMIGA_MAGS

Hello Paul.

01 Apr 96 19:05, Paul West wrote to Ian Muirhead:



 PW> For you to be able to do what you're doing now, you must have the
 PW> facilities and abilities to do it - ie to write the said messages. You
 PW> only do it because those facilities and abilities are there, and you
 PW> only CAN do it for those reasons. You couldn't just go and levitate
 PW> just because you chose to do so - you'd have to learn how. Thus, what
 PW> you choose to do is only within what is possible, and that is the
 PW> extent of free choice. You can't choose to do things which aren't
 PW> possible. You can't choose to do things which don't have a place in

But whats possible has absolutely nothing to do with fate, it's more to do with the laws of Physics, I can not levitate, because it breaks a load of them...


 PW> The whole situation surrounding your writing of messages here is only
 PW> supported by the rest of reality making it possible. Your finances,
 PW> your posessions, all aquired over time by what's possible. Certainly
 PW> there are possibilities within your limits, which you can choose from,
 PW> but I'm suggesting that your limits are not defined directly by you.

I'm afraid I do not accept this at all, I stil contend there is no such thing as fate, it is all chance and probability, putting it another way, if there is a fate, who/what defines it?...


 IM>> Rubbish, everybody makes their own destinies, if you feel your
 IM>> life going down the toilet, you make an effort to change...

 PW> You don't entirely make your own destiny. Your part in it concerns
 PW> your use of your own resources. You are free to grow and learn, and
 PW> are free to be what you are and do whatever you're capable of doing,
 PW> but you cannot do things which are beyond yourself until you learn how
 PW> to. Right now at this point in time you are not able to give birth to
 PW> a child. Therefore, you are not free to do so. That is just one basic
 PW> example of the restrictions placed on you from outside. You also do
 PW> not have the ability to have a period; to fly like a bird; to spend
 PW> your life underwater breathing dissolve oxygen. The extent of your
 PW> choice is limited to what is possible within yourself. If you wanna
 PW> have a baby you've gotta grow and change and become a woman. Obviously
 PW> there are restrictions on how you might do that.

I've hear some strange arguements in my time, but this is verging on the rediculous, I do not call what sex I am as fate, I call it biology and X/Y Chromasones<sp?>

 PW> Contrary to popular belief, fate is not anything to do with past
 PW> present and future as such. There is a natural `law' which sais that
 PW> you are free to be what you are, but ONLY what you are, and that if
 PW> you want to be more
 PW> you have to first become more. This applies to any moment in time. It
 PW> does not mean that it lays out the whole of your life in a script
 PW> which you act from. But, due to that restriction, it basically DOES do
 PW> that. IOW it has the same effect. Your future isn't written in stone
 PW> as it were, but certainly the things which can happen in the future
 PW> depend very much on what you are now, and of course what you are now
 PW> is the future of what you once were. Thus, although there isn't real
 PW> predefined fate, the laws of nature dictates that precicely the same
 PW> effect occurs.

Err, I give up! :-/


Ian

---
 * Origin: Temporary Origin while testing Fastecho... (2:2501/10.1)