From Ian Muirhead · 1996-04-06 09:20 · #74249 in AMIGA_MAGS
Well Met Martin, On Thursday, 4 April 1996, Martin Donlon Spoketh to Ian Muirhead About: "Gods" MD> Hi Ian, Hmmm...This is starting to get confusing:) Ok. A person MD> gets attacked, the person who attacked them did evil. If you went up MD> and helped them you would be doing good. But what about if you tried MD> to help them but you ended up doing them more harm? You would then MD> be doing evil even though you had good intentions. By not helping MD> them and IM>> Hmm, thats a new angle, but helping could be defined as calling IM>> an ambulance, how could that harm somebody... MD> Ok I think this boils down to wether good intentions are MD> automatically good. I don't know how to get around this...Did you ever In general, yes, if you were trying to help somebody then it is good, However, if you display severe incompetance, like moving somebody who'd just fallen off a building, then that would not be good, although you could not claasify it as evil, just because you didn't know what you were doing, we need something inbetween that is not neutral... MD> read Good Omens, I think that might explain it somewhere. Errm, fraid not, the only Pterry book that I haven't... MD>>> by not harming them you are not doing good (the person can MD>>> die),but you are not doing evil(you did not personally harm the MD>>> person). You are just sort of ignoring it. I don't think this has MD>>> sorted anything:( Do you?? IM>> Not really, no, we still seem to be at an enpass... MD> My mind is thumping trying to get my head around this.... Ok. What MD> you are saying is that all good intentions are good and that would mean MD> that all other intentions are evil. But there are numourous occasions MD> when good intentions turn to evil.......Sod it. err... no, just in the context of ignoring a person who _WILL_ die without your assistance, you were saying that a person who did not help was neutral, I contend that there is no such thing as neutrality, every single person on the planet has urges one way or other... and as for good intentions turning to evil, name one (as long as it doesn't come from the bibble ;) ) IM>>>> Be seeing you Martin, MD>>> As long as you help me if you see me injured down an alley ;) IM>> I'll think about it ;) MD> Is think evil, evil?? err, No, as I am thinking about it now, if I saw you in an alley, I would help, depending upon your injuries, it would range from helping you up to calling an ambulance, so I suppose, technically I would be thinking about which course of action I should take which would cause least distress... And this is getting very deep.... IM>> 2:255/1 Trinity Midnight Line John Burden MNL MD> Where is this ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^? Dublin?? No, Exeter, Devon... By your leave, Martin. Ian Muirhead [Moderator MYTH] Saturday, 6 April 1996, 3:31. BBSNet: 405:100/89.1 * PsychoNet: 1080:118/1.2 .!. From the trees Teut draws out many beutiful spirits with healing, cartharic .!. and defensive powers, whose chief is Esus. Into the stones Teut writes the .!. records and infuses the messages of the higher worlds. .!. Nuinn (The Book of Druidry) --- Terminate 3.00 * Origin: The Silver Dragons Lair, off the Pleasure Dome BBS (2:2501/10.1)