From Michael Shearer · 1996-04-01 19:15 · #74218 in AMIGA_MAGS
PW> It might be a good idea to drop this shanegan about deception PW> and being able to detect it because there is no way to draw an PW> accurate line or limit. If you want confirmation, then take my PW> word for it that I know I'm deceiving myself but I know not PW> how. I will work it out eventually, but my way. This is a recipe for continued self-deception. To be any good your self-defence mechanisms would have to be good enough to cope with any attempts you may make to thwart them. This is why we need other people to point them out & to insist on doing so. We need other people. You can't go it alone without being doomed to failure. PW> Other than that I don't like to assume anything. I question as PW> much as is questionable. For example, yesterday my blue shirt PW> was scrunched up in my drawer. I went out. I came back in PW> later and my blue shirt was hung up and ironed. It was not PW> mentioned how it got there. I did not assume that mum had PW> ironed it, for it could have been caused by something else, PW> telekinesis included. Would you assume that it had been ironed PW> by the person who uses the iron? No, but I'd strongly recommend that you iron your own shirts. MS> How can an event be uncaused? PW> That logic doesn't come into it because what I suggested is PW> beyond that logic. You used the phrase 'uncaused event' not me. It doesn't seem unreasonable to ask you what you mean. PW> I suppose your definition of `event' is something resulting PW> from a cause, or thereabouts. No, it's what happens. PW> I'm saying that `events', things which we perceive as being PW> things, through feeback and contrast, are in themselves an PW> effect AND a cause. For example, a hammer causes a nail to be PW> driven into wood, but the hammering action is also the result PW> of my holding and moving it. So the hammer is a cause and an PW> effect. All `things' are a cause and an effect, so I deduce PW> that all things are BOTH. The concept of something being more PW> than one thing goes against logic, and against causality Not at all, on the contrary, I'd say that this is so stunningly obvious that it's not worth saying. Beside the fact that something is both a cause & an effect has nothing to do with the possibility of an uncaused event. PW> Rather, it implies a both/and situation, from which I deduce PW> that it is either uncaused or has an infinite number of PW> `causes'. It can never have ONE cause because one `thing' PW> within a larger `One' whole is like saying that it is seperate PW> of the whole, which it is not. Fine, but lots of causes doesn't mean uncaused. So could you answer the question? Michael --- * Origin: Psychonautica BBS +44 0181 7641446 Dreams/Occult/UFO+ (2:254/284)