Slimelite BBS

Extra-terrestrial life?

Back to AMIGA_MAGS

From Laurence Taylor · 1996-03-31 02:31 · #74168 in AMIGA_MAGS

 -=> Quoting stephen dickson to All <=-

 sd> 1) Life arose on *this* planet, Earth, a few hundred million years ago
 sd> - we know from the fossil record, very precisely, the enviromental
 sd> conditions of that era. (The atmosphere was a mixture of nitrogen and
 sd> carbon compounds.) Therefore since we can simulate the conditions
 sd> present on that early earth very accurately - why have we been unable
 sd> to reproduce the spontaneous evolution of life? 

Because we haven't waited long enough for it to happen. I believe we
have been able to produce amino acids (the basis for DNA) by duplicating
the conditions on primordial Earth; however, for any even slightly
advanced form of life to occur would take thousands even millions of
years - we can't hurry it up in the laboratory, therefore we haven't
been able to do it.

 sd> 2) Assuming life arose on other planets in the universe, knowing the
 sd> darwinian theories of evolution, the chances of life forms arising in
 sd> any way similar to our own are incredulously remote. At each
 sd> evolutionary pathway on earth, any of two or three branches could have
 sd> continued on to the next stage, multiply this be a few million years
 sd> of evolution and you get very remote chances indeed. So, if life arose
 sd> on other planets, who is to say that we would recognise it as being
 sd> self-aware?

Does it matter, as long as IT can? In fact, it is likely that we would
indeed recognise some form of alien life, providing it was at a
sufficiently advanced stage to be distinguishable from, say, rock.

 sd> 3) Viruses - no one can even hazard a sensible guess as to how viruses
 sd> evolved. Viruses are not technically alive, but are just incredibly
 sd> complex chains of chemicals shaped in particular manners to carry the
 sd> replication DNA/RNA. How can we expect to show life on other planets
 sd> before understanding what life itself is on our own planet? Most people
 sd> when asked would say a virus is a form of life - but it does not
 sd> respire, nor does it consume food as such. It has no sexual
 sd> reproduction, and cannot provide any form of motion - yet it is the
 sd> most ancient and wide-spread form of "life" we know. 

I have come across this question before - but never any attempt to
answer it. And I can't answer it either, except to say that there are
exceptions to every rule.

rgds
LAurence

... "Bother," said Pooh, as Eeyore sneezed crack all over Owl
--- Blue Wave v2.12 [NR]
 * Origin: ATTiTuDE! ... A BiT GiNGeR PRoDucTIon... 0181 204 0891 (2:254/400)