Slimelite BBS

Libarys

Back to PRATCHETT

From Graham Marsden · 1996-04-13 21:53 · #74122 in PRATCHETT

Hi Ian,

[Re: most Fantasy is basically LOTR rewritten...]

 GM> Thinking of Shan^H^H^H^H any particular books? ;-)

IM> No doubt you've read my feelings on Shannara ;)...

Well, oddly enough...!

 GM> I think the thing is that LOTR set a defining standard for Fantasy
 GM> did it in such a way that it created a mould which almost any future
 GM> Fantasy story couldn't *help* but fit in in some way or another.

IM> Absolutely, all fantasy has a link with it, from elves, to the
IM> Early 14c technology level...

The question is, of course, can Fantasy be written *without* these sorts of
elements? Ok, you can get rid of Elves, but they'll be replaced by something
else. You can set it in a different genre, but then is it Fantasy, eg Shadow
Run? Is Fantasy just stuck in a rut or is this such a fundamental definition
of Fantasy that it can't be anything else?

IM> Most fantasy I've seen has grabbed from various Myths, I'd be hard
IM> pressed to name one which didn't...

But is it just that the various myths just got there first?

[Re: Space: Above and Beyond]

 GM>> because I would have given it *such* a slating based only on the
 GM>> pilot (cliche rides again!) but I want to give it a fair chance

 IM>> Judging by some of the other episodes, you can give it a slating
 IM>> based on them as well...

Yes, but... ok, I'm going to do it in a couple of messages time...

Cheers,
Graham.

--- GEcho/32 1.20/Pro
 * Origin: METRIC BBS * 01705 871471 * Multi Line * V34 28k8 * (2:251/21)