Slimelite BBS

Re: Star Wars Killed the SF Film!!

Back to PRATCHETT

From Paul Walker · 1996-04-12 23:53 · #74073 in PRATCHETT

In reply to Re: Star Wars Killed the SF Film!! by Paul Walker

Hi Mark,

Quoting Mark Stevens to Paul Walker, on 08 Apr 96  07:25:00,
about Star Wars Killed the SF Film!!.
 
 GM>> But that's only two films out of *how many*? Why can't we have
 GM>> more 2001's and Blade Runner's? What is it about these films that
 PW> They were both based on book's by excellent authors, and happened to
 PW> get a good director as well? (Even though Kubrick messed up the end of
 PW> 2001, IMO)

 MS> In '2001's case, it was a collaborative effort between Clarke and
 MS> Kubrick. The movie was released before the novel. It's true to say

It was? Strange. I know that the film was based on the novel.

 MS> that '2001' had its routes in Clarke's 'The Sentinel' short story

Yep, even Clarke himself says that :-)

 MS> though. I thought the ending to '2001' was perfect. 

Really? I couldn't make head or tail out of it. TBH, it looked like someone had
taken some strange drug, had a trip, and then said "I know, let's film what I
just experienced!"

 GM>> My contention is, however, that it has become too easy to put in
 GM>> flashy special effects where the character and plot development
 PW> That's the "fault" of technology in general, for progressing to the
 MS> No, it's the fault of people who misuse the technology, not the
 MS> technology itself. 

Okay, I'll admit defeat on this! :-) Can't remember why I put the original
sentence, actually.

 PW> As an interesting aside, it wasn't actually his idea to do all the FX
 PW> the way they were done, he was going to use models etc...
 MS> Wuh? Star Wars *is* entirely models-based. What did you think it was?

Oops. Sorry - wrong description. I meant to say he was going to use the same
style that they did in, for example, the "Jason and the Argonauts" film.

 _
|_)                      
|  aul                   paul.walker@esoftc.seuk.com     <No files>

... A miser is hard to live with, but makes a fine ancestor.
--- Blue Wave v2.12 [NR]
 * Origin: Highlander BB's - Gloucester [ +44-1452-384702/557 ] (2:253/418)