Slimelite BBS

Good books - Killian

Back to PRATCHETT

From Robert Bull · 1996-04-12 02:05 · #74005 in PRATCHETT

In reply to Re: Good books by Eoghann Irving

Hello, Eoghann;

06 Apr 96 12:41, Eoghann Irving wrote to Robert Bull:

 RB>> "Eyas" is marvellous, genuinely unique; certainly I've never read

 EI> Sounds intrigueing.  I've read quite a few books that try to move from
 EI> fantasy to SF.  Most of them fail miserably.  When it works it's
 EI> usually quite impressive though.

You might find this fails, perhaps because of failing to achieve great 
ambition.  But don't let that put you off.  It's terrific, even if I'm the 
only fan I know of.  The book is so completely /different/ it's worth 
tracking down.

 EI> I've got one book of his.  Its called Greenmagic.  Its an American
 EI> import with a hideous cover and the back cover isn't very inspiring
 EI> either.  Is that the one you mean?  There's actually a lot more to it

I can't remember the title, but the cover I saw had a bunch of beaming all- 
American kids straight off the set of one of their upbeat family soaps.  If 
the book is good, then it wouldn't be the first time I've been lead astray 
by stupid cover art or publisher's blurb.

 EI> Actually, looking inside the book I've found a short list of his other
 EI> books. The Chronoplane Wars:

 EI> Well we've covered Eyas and Greenmagic.  Have you heard of any of the
 EI> others? Does anyone know if they are published in Britain?

I haven't heard of any of the others, and have only seen "Eyas" and the one 
mentioned above.  Perhaps he really does need a better agent to promote his 
work.

 RB>> Not yet - not supposed to be quite as good as "Tigana" but still
 RB>> better than most of the field.

 EI> I don't know if I could pick a favourite between the two.  It
 EI> certainly has the same adult approach that Tigana had.  Definately
 EI> worth reading.

He's certainly getting known for the grwon-up approach.  Most people seem 
to agree that "A Song for Arbonne" is the next best to "Tigana.

 EI> Magic tends to be quite low key in his books.  Its still fairly

That's a reason why I feel a bit ambivalent about it; it isn't sufficiently 
numinous, somehow.  That is, there's little feel of "otherness" about it.  
Perhaps that comes from liking Barbara Hambly, where the magic is very much 
centre stage.  One practical bone I would pick with "Tigana" is that none 
of the magicians seem to have much in the way of books of lore or magical 
paraphernalia, nor do they seem to have had to go through any period of 
training or learning, and that seems to me unreasonable given the power 
they are supposed to have.

 EI> central to the plot usually though.  Is it out in hardback or
 EI> paperback?

I think I saw a note in this echo within the last siz months.  Par for the 
course would put the paperback release sometime within the next six months, 
as they often appear a year apart.  Your bookseller might know.

     Regards,

              Robert.

--- GoldED 2.50+
 * Origin: Pointing at Minerva * 28 lines/12Gigs * 0181-402-3350 (2:254/33.4)