From Graham Marsden · 1996-04-10 04:28 · #73959 in PRATCHETT
Hi Ray, [Re: Star Wars has actually done more harm to the SF genre than good] GM> There *have* been SF films which haven't relied on flashy special GM> effects, eg 2001: where the effects were so good that they could be GM> ignored (for the most part). RB> So in 2001: Etc. there were no flashy models or fancy sets? RB> No? How about weird film processes or strange lighting effects? RB> No? That's strange. 2001: A Space Odyssey was the /height/ of RB> flashy special effects when it was released. No, Ray, you miss the point. The effects were *so good* that they effectively *ceased to be* special effects. IMO that is what effects should be about, not that you think "wow, what great effects", but that you concentrate on what the *story* is doing. RB> In fact, IMHO that was what saved it from its completely unintelligable RB> ending. (I had to go and read the book to find out what on earth RB> happened in the end sequence, and I have _NEVER_ met anyone who RB> understood it just from watching it. Ray Barker? Pleased to meet you. My name is Graham Marsden... ;-) I saw the film when I was about 15 and, whilst I can't say that I *fully* understood it (it is not the sort of thing than you *can* fully understand immediately), I certainly did get the basic point that Mankind, for all its clever toys and spacecraft is still a primitive, or a baby, in cosmic terms. RB> _Surely_ that is not the mark of a good film? That depends whether you like having your drama spoonfed to you with nice explanations for the hard of thinking, or whether you like something which leaves you thinking. RB> (I like /most/ of it, but surely my point about the end is one that RB> most agree with...) Clarke commented that film critics were so used to watching films made for 12 year old minds that they had *ended up with* 12 year old minds! What is so difficult to understand? The clues are there. The Monolith arrives on Earth and teaches the ape-men to make tools which progress until they become spacecraft. Incidentally he also creates "tools of destruction" and "thinking tools" and thinks he is so clever, but he abuses them and they backfire on him. The space faring ape-men get to the moon to find the next "pointer" and it takes them nineteen months to get to Jupiter. The ape-man encounters the monolith again which, in the space of a few minutes, takes him "beyond the infinite" and further than his mind can comprehend. The ape-man discovers that, far from being "master of all he surveys" he is, in fact, less than a baby in terms of the cosmos. The only point in the film which I feel could have been made clearer was that in the four million year "flash forward", the bone becomes an orbiting nuclear bomb, pointing out how the ape-man was shown how to make a tool which could feed him and which he promptly used for destruction. Cheers, Graham. --- GEcho/32 1.20/Pro * Origin: METRIC BBS * 01705 871471 * Multi Line * V34 28k8 * (2:251/21)