From Jayne Johnson · 1996-04-08 03:00 · #73909 in PRATCHETT
In reply to Re: Star Wars Killed the SF Film!! by Paul Walker
In a message dated 01 Apr 96 13:06:53 Graham Marsden wrote: GM> [Re: Star Wars has actually done more harm to the SF genre than good] GM> JJ> Are you saying that if the Star Wars trilogy had never been made, we GM> JJ> would now be seeing films without loads of special effects, but with GM> JJ> better plots? GM> GM> Not necessarily, but Hollywood mainly runs on the "band wagon" principle, GM> if someone comes up with a successful formula it will be copied ad GM> infinitum. Since Star Wars we've had lots of films with tons of effects GM> and no plots. But Hollywood has always run on the bandwagon principle! Before the advent of special effects films relied on big name stars to bring in the punters. GM> Yes, they made use of the technology, but did they make *good* use of it? GM> Wouldn't Star Wars have been better if there *had* been a plot and the GM> characters weren't two dimensional? Perhaps we would still have exactly GM> the same as we have today, but we might not. I think they made good use of it. I also think that Star Wars had a great plot, and good characters. GM> JJ> Well these types of films have always existed, not just in the SciFi GM> JJ> genre. It's coz they're made by Americans! GM> GM> I don't deny that, but don't we, the audience, have a right to expect GM> better than mass market mind candy? Of course we do! But there's always going to be films that are all hype and little else. Films like Judge Dredd, Batman and the awful Mutant Turtles & Mario Brothers are relying more I think on the popular character concept than on special effects. After all, nowadays SFX aren't such a big deal, we've come to expect them, and we aren't as impressed as we would have been a few years ago. A couple more years and we won't even notice them. GM> JJ> I liked Star Wars... The other films you mention, such as Batman & GM> Judge JJ> Dredd were a complete load of crap. GM> GM> But why? What differentiates them? They all had lots of effects, some had GM> big name stars, why did some work and not the others? Well like I said, I think Star Wars & some others like Terminator 2 and Close Encounters did have good plots etc., the SFX were a bonus (for me, anyway) I enjoyed the films themselves. I watched about 30 minutes of Batman and turned the telly over because I was bored out of my skull! See ya Jayne ... The moving cat sheds, and having shed, moves on. ___ Offline Orbit v0.80 (Unregistered Evaluation Copy) --- * Origin: Black Ice (2:255/78)