Slimelite BBS

Another Load of Book Reviews

Back to PRATCHETT

From Ian Muirhead · 1996-04-07 16:27 · #73894 in PRATCHETT

Graham Marsden wrote in a message to Ian Muirhead:


IM> present a small ramdom selection of the books I have read over the past
IM> few months, and my opinions of them...

 GM> Good man! 

IM> Shadow Moon - George Lucas & Chris Claremont

IM> Oh dear, things have not improved from the film upon which this
IM> book was based (anybody remember 'Willow', anybody want to?),

 GM> I remember it. Unfortunately!

Yep, it was dire...


IM> Armageddon - The Musical

 GM> I looked at this one a few days back, but it just totally failed to
 GM> inspire me. I got the impression that the author was just trying
 GM> *too hard* to make it funny and it just didn't work for me.

I liked his utterly silly sense of humour, though saying that, I found the last book in the trilogy, The Suburban Book Of The Dead, rather dull and boring...


IM> Grunts - Mary Gentle

IM> One word, Inspired [...] it is a laugh to read from
IM> start to finish, if you like Pratchett, you'll love this... :)

 GM> Hmm, I liked it and it was funny, but I had the feeling that it was
 GM> made up from four short stories cobbled together and it just seemed
 GM> to go on too long for my tastes so the humour faded a bit at the
 GM> end.

I didn't really get that impression, except at the end where the story did a right turn down a completely different path....



By Your leave, Ian 


---
 * Origin:       I'm too sexy for this origin       (2:2501/10.1)