From Graham Marsden · 1996-04-06 23:48 · #73866 in PRATCHETT
Hi Ian,
[Re: Unoriginal plots]
IM>> Can you honestly name one book which is utterly original, that
IM>> hasn't ripped the plot from anywhere...
GM> No, because there are (supposedly) only seven basic plots, however
GM> it is the *way* that the plots are used.
IM> Hmm, yes, I agree with that, but most Fantasy goes further than
IM> that and is basically LOTR rewritten...
Thinking of Shan^H^H^H^H any particular books? ;-)
I think the thing is that LOTR set a defining standard for Fantasy and did
it in such a way that it created a mould which almost any future Fantasy
story couldn't *help* but fit in in some way or another.
Although it could be claimed that LOTR merely copied from practially every
mythform that ever existed such that you can't write *any* Fantasy without
looking like it.
There again, I did overhear Mark telling Luke and John that Matthew was
suing them for breach of copyright...! ;-)
IM> The person who can Name all seven plots will win a prize of my
IM> choosing :)
And gets to read the Message Stats in a style of the Moderator's choosing!
;-)
GM> reason why I have not yet commented on Space: Above and Beyond, because
GM> I would have given it *such* a slating based only on the pilot (cliche
GM> rides again!) but I want to give it a fair chance and I'm going to
GM> watch a couple more episodes before I say anything.
IM> Judging by some of the other episodes, you can give it a slating
IM> based on them as well...
I don't know, I *really* don't know. I might get around to writing it in a
couple of messages time or I might wait until I've seen another episode.
IM> * Origin: Melnibon?, off the Pleasure Dome BBS (2:2501/10.1)
^
BTW, just as a personal favour to me, I know Melnibone is supposed to end
with an accent, but the high ascii character causes my editor to glitch and
throw the message out as it thinks it's a binary file. Could you possibly
drop the accent? Thanks.
Cheers,
Graham.
--- GEcho/32 1.20/Pro
* Origin: METRIC BBS * 01705 871471 * Multi Line * V34 28k8 * (2:251/21)