Slimelite BBS

Re: Asimov

Back to PRATCHETT

From Ray Barker · 1996-04-05 02:48 · #73827 in PRATCHETT

In reply to Re: Asimov by Ian Muirhead

 As my Black&Lee PowerMann bit into the eye of Tony Pressley...
 
 TP> If I was going to start reading his books, I would try and read them
 TP> in the order of publication, rather than chronolical order. This is

 LM> Oh dear.  I was planning to read 'Prelude' first. Mainly cos it's the
 LM> only Foundation book I've located so far.

 TP> Some of his later tales, tell of times that happened before his
 TP> earlier stories. Often these later stories will contain a twist that
 TP> relies on your knowledge of his earlier stuff, and may spoil your

 LM> I would have thought that reading the stories that take place before
 LM> his early stuff would give more background and so enable you to better
 LM> understand what happens and why...

Yes, but the stories in Foundation do not rely on you knowing about What Hari
Seldon had done before, or on knowing about the second foundation, et al.
and instead tell you _everything_ you need to know. The latterly published
books tend to rely heavily on What Has Gone Before so you can go "Aaah! So 
thats why A did B to C, causing D." rather than "Eh? That makes no  
sense! I'm not reading this rubbish!"... 

... Where there's a will, there's a won't.
--- Blue Wave v2.12 [NR]
 * Origin: Alba Maximus, Glasgow [Line1 0141 880 7863 V34] (2:259/2)