Slimelite BBS

Re: Readers survey in SFX

Back to PRATCHETT

From Paul Walker · 1996-04-06 07:52 · #73813 in PRATCHETT

In reply to Re: Readers survey in SFX by Paul Moss

Hi Ian,

On 30 Mar 96  05:03:21, Ian Muirhead was talking to Paul Walker
about Re: Readers survey in SFX...

[Shannara]
 MD>> Apart from the Elfstones, which was the "best" of the lot. They are
 MD>> just different storylines slotted to fit the same template and the
 MD>> same characters:(
 PW> That's what *all* books, set in the same "universe" (excluding
 PW> trilogies etc obviously) are, isn't it??? Wake up! :)
 IM> Not at all, The Dragonlance series do not have all the same characters
 IM> in all the books, and besides they are much more readible than the
 IM> shannara series by virtue of being better written...

That's annoying - I can't cut any of that. :-/

Neither did Shannara have the same characters - the only one who remained
consistent was Allanon, whereas DL have Raistlin, Caramon, etc. And I know
Raistlin is still around in "Dragons..." !

I think we'll just stop the argument here, though. I didn't find them that bad,
same as people didn't seem to find the Mission Earth things too bad. :-/

We're descending into the realms of "Yes it is", "no it isn't" [and also...
horror... subjectivity! Quick, someone call Paul W**t... no, on second
thoughts ;-) ]

 IM> .!. "That wasn't a demi-lich you just stepped on, was it?"

Ugh, wondered what that was on the bottom of my shoe. ;-) BAZAMM!
 _
|_)                      <UI120:MTFFBGASCETDFFMLCFEJDIMNLFFDBHMFDBBUOCKACGD
|  aul                   paul.walker@esoftc.seuk.com     <No files>

... -- Nature always sides with the hidden flaw! --
--- Blue Wave v2.12 [NR]
 * Origin: Highlander BB's - Gloucester [ +44-1452-384702/557 ] (2:253/418)