Slimelite BBS

Star Wars Killed the SF Film!!

Back to PRATCHETT

From Graham Marsden · 1996-04-02 00:06 · #73765 in PRATCHETT

Hi Jayne,

[Re: Star Wars has actually done more harm to the SF genre than good]

JJ> Well I'm not sure I can agree with you on this one.

Good, you weren't supposed to! ;-)

JJ> Are you saying that if the Star Wars trilogy had never been made, we
JJ> would now be seeing films without loads of special effects, but with
JJ> better plots?

Not necessarily, but Hollywood mainly runs on the "band wagon" principle, if
someone comes up with a successful formula it will be copied ad infinitum.
Since Star Wars we've had lots of films with tons of effects and no plots.

JJ> Star Wars may have been the pioneer of SFX, but don't you think it
JJ> would have happened anyway? Lucas films didn't invent technology, they
JJ> just made good use of it!

Yes, they made use of the technology, but did they make *good* use of it?
Wouldn't Star Wars have been better if there *had* been a plot and the
characters weren't two dimensional? Perhaps we would still have exactly the
same as we have today, but we might not.

[Re: Star Wars, ET, Close Encounters, Terminator 2]

JJ> Well these types of films have always existed, not just in the SciFi
JJ> genre. It's coz they're made by Americans!

I don't deny that, but don't we, the audience, have a right to expect better
than mass market mind candy?

JJ> I liked Star Wars... The other films you mention, such as Batman & Judge
JJ> Dredd were a complete load of crap.

But why? What differentiates them? They all had lots of effects, some had
big name stars, why did some work and not the others?

JJ> But I think they would have been forced upon us regardless of whether
JJ> or not Star Wars had ever been made!

I'm not so sure. As I said above, what if Star Wars had had a plot as well
as all the flashy effects? Would we be looking at better films now?

Cheers,
Graham.

--- GEcho/32 1.20/Pro
 * Origin: METRIC BBS * 01705 871471 * Multi Line * V34 28k8 * (2:251/21)