From Mark Stevens · 1996-03-30 22:08 · #73753 in PRATCHETT
Wednesday March 27 1996 23:24, Ian Muirhead wrote to Graham Marsden:
GM>> I was thinking about SF and the like and I've come to the
GM>> conclusion that George Lucas's film Star Wars has actually done
GM>> more harm to the SF genre than good.
IM> Hmm, I don't know about that, when it was first released, it sure got
IM> a lot of new fans interested in SF...
And I reckon the new trilogy will make SF even more popular and generate plenty more decent SF movies.
IM> I think the bigger problem is the inability of Hillywood to convert
IM> an SF novel to the medium of the screen, just too much either gets
IM> changed or left out, changing the entire character of the story...
You've also got to consider that the mediums of film and the novel aren't completely compatible. If there is a problem with SF films, then it's that there aren't many that are actually made with the cinematic medium in mind. Those that are ('2001', 'Star Wars' and 'Blade Runner') tend to do better (at least on a critical level) whereas those that are mere conversions ('Judge Dredd', 'Dune', 'Flash Gordon') aren't as successful. Take 'Dune' for instance, it was trying to *be* the novel on a cinema screen, and that just doesn't work.
The reverse is true as well -- cinematic spectaculars don't make for good novels. It makes me laugh when people go, "Well, I've read the novelisation of 'Strange Days' and it's a bit crap. I won't see the film now." They're forgetting that 'Strange Days' was never intended to be a novel -- it's a film, and that's the medium in which it works. Cameron and Bigelow set out to make it an experience best enjoyed on a huge 40 foot screen with Dolby Surround, not as some two-bit 170 page novelisation by a literary nobody.
GM>> Star Wars: A cowboy film in space with good guys in white and bad
GM>> guys in black.
IM> Wern't the troopers white? ;)
Yeah, and Luke's all dressed in black from Empire onwards! Still, just to help those that might get a bit confused, the goodies have blue/green lasers and the baddies have red ones.
GM>> ET: A modern day "Famous Five" story with heroic kids and evil
GM>> adults
IM> It must have had something, the public loved it, it really relied on
IM> the 'Cutesy' effect, without that, I doubt the film would have been
IM> half a popular...
What Graham is doing is breaking these SF films down to their constituent elements and going, "Look -- see it's crap." But you can apply this argument to *anything*. He cited Alien as an example of a proper, decent sci-fi film, but it's just a 'hunt the runaway' plot.
GM>> Terminator 2: a chase movie with a time travel sub plot and tons
GM>> of pretty effects.
IM> And ever since, every SF film worth it's salt has had morphing...
'Strange Days' didn't.
GM>> Judge Dredd: Wrongly convicted hero tries to clear his name with
GM>> a "revenge" sub plot with mammoth sets.
IM> But it also goes to prove that the public will only take so much, it
IM> may have looked good, but it was an awful film...
Going back to my point about the viability of something (such as Dredd) between two mediums. Dredd's great comic book material, but is it great movie material? Well, actually I think it is -- it's just that Danny Cannon tackled it the wrong way. He went for a version with mass-market appeal and kicked the comic book continuity out of the window. As it is, the comic-book version of Dredd simply *isn't* something that would appeal to a mass audience.
So there we have a breach of the comic book's integrity, which didn't need to happen. Okay, so with an $80M movie on his hands, Danny Cannon *had* to rework the premise, but then if this was all for the benefit of a mass-market audience, then perhaps Judge Dredd was the wrong film to do it with. Why not create a new comic book style super hero, or something, and spend the $80M on that. If a Judge Dredd movie needs to be made (and I'm not convinced that it does), then it's better going for a more European style movie, perhaps with a lower budget and a more grittier feel. In my opinion, Richard Stanley (Hardware, Dust Devil) would have been the right director for that sort of approach to Judge Dredd.
GM>> It is my contention that Hollywood (that place of superficial
GM>> glitz and glamour) has been so seduced by the "look what we can
GM>> do with the lights" mentality that they have failed to apply the
GM>> basic rules of what makes a good film to the SF genre (perhaps to
GM>> *any* genre, but certainly SF).
IM> again, I think this is the film industry in general...
I agree. I find it ridiculous that 'Star Wars' should be blamed for every cinematic failing, least of all those in the sci-fi genre.
IM> look at the action film genre, each film has bigger and better SFX,
IM> taking up so much screen time, the plot somehow gets forgotten
Although on occasion these big-budget action extravaganzas can be fun. There's nothing particularly complex about a roller-coaster ride, but it's brilliant fun whilst it lasts. In a similar fashion, something like 'True Lies' is a film where you can leave your brain behind and just enjoy the fun.
.+'''+. fido ¯ 2:254/151.27 & 2:254/255.27
M A R K email ¯ mark@sonance.demon.co.uk
`+.,.+' www ¯ http://www.netlink.co.uk/users/sonance/
--- GEcho 1.00
* Origin: Sunbathing on the Exocet Deck (2:254/151.27)