Slimelite BBS

Another Load of Book Reviews

Back to PRATCHETT

From Ian Muirhead · 1996-04-01 02:14 · #73733 in PRATCHETT

Well met All,

Well, nodoubt you've seen my C/R lines at the bottom of my messages (and
nodoubt cursed them as you see the same book in 15 messages :) ), but have
not been given any idea of what I thought of them, so here I present a small
ramdom selection of the books I have read over the past few months, and my
opinions of them...
                   

Shadow Moon - George Lucas & Chris Claremont
============================================

Oh dear, things have not improved from the film upon which this book was
based (anybody remember 'Willow', anybody want to?), it basically continues
10 years after the film left off, things have not improved much, and the
usual dark forces want to rule the world.  Now I am usually very forgiving
when it comes to quality of writing and general plot, but this book is one of
the most uninspired pieces of writing that I have had the misfortune to read,
the plot limps along with very little happening, aside from an occasional
conversation with a stone, the only real action happened three quarters into
the book, and then for a scant few pages before it relapsed into the standard
drag, this is one book that could do with a major editing...


The Paradise War - Stephen Lawhead
==================================

Now this I liked, fast paced, believable characters, and a very large dose of
Celtic Mythology, it concerns strange occurances happening in Oxford, and a
trip to a cairn in Scotland, things escalte from there when the main players
find themselves in the 'otherworld'.  A great writing style, and it did not
drag one bit.  It is the first in a trilogy, I have yet to track down the
others, but if they are the same quality as the first, I shall not be
disapointed...


Dragons of Summer Flame - Margaret Weis & Tracy Hickman (Dragonlance)
=====================================================================

A must read for all Dragonlance fans, this book, the fourth in the chronicles
series, concludes the current book era, it is set 25 years after the War of
the Lance, and the companions have mostly split up, however, all is not well,
The Dark Queen has learnt from her defeats and a new menace is in the land,
Dark Paladins, the story is centred on Palin Majere, who must stop the
catastrophy unfolding....  It is an excellent book, and rounds the series off
nicely, it also serves as an introduction to the new era of Krynn, The first
book in the 5th Age series is due in August.



Knights of the Sword - Roland Green (Dragonlance)
=================================================

Yet another DL book, this one, however is rather better than some of the
recent efforts, it basically concerns a Solamnic Knights rise from being a
Knight of the Crown (Previous book) to a Knight of the Rose (Next book in
series), and the adventures he gets inolved in, although nothing too deep,
the book does what it's supposed to and provides a nice little read, no more,
no less...


Armageddon - The Musical
========================

And now for some light relief, this book is perfect for those who love
rediculous comedy, it's packed full of it, from a time travelling Sprout, to
a post holocaust nuclear bunker age, where all there is to do is watch TV and
earn food credits provided by the TV Companies who are owned by the big three
Religions which are run by Dalai Dan,  L. Ron Hubbard the twentythird and
Pope Joan respectively.  It is absolutely brilliant, and has the same
characters (and sprouts) that crop up in quite a few of his other books...


Grunts - Mary Gentle
====================

One word, Inspired, she has taken a standard Fantasy and turned it on its
head, Marine Orcs, elves deep in jungle warfare, war trials, elite undead
special forces, cyborgs, shes got the lot, and it is all from the bad guys
point of view, although not suitable for children, it is a laugh to read from
start to finish, if you like Pratchett, you'll love this... :)

Rats and Gargoyles - Mary Gentle
================================

Hmm, I don't really know what to make of this one, it's got a good enough
story, but I couldn't help wondering what the point of it was, it seemed to
throw you straight into the story without a clue as to what was going on, all
in all, I'm indiferant over it...

-!----------------------

Well, thats it, a couple of Corkers, one stinker, and a few averages, not a
bad cross section IMO...



I bid you farewell All
Scribed on Sunday, 31 March 1996 at 20:15
                                    [Moderator MYTH]
          /=-                   "Est Sularus oth Mithas"
   +====(*)||>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>=-   BBSNet:    405:100/89.1
          \=-                    PsychoNet: 1080:118/1.2

.!. Big juicy Apples, Dag Nammit !
.!.                                                  ---=> Apple Tango <=---
--- Terminate 3.00
 * Origin: The Black Knights Realm, off the Pleasure Dome BBS (2:2501/10.1)