Slimelite BBS

Re: Help! Wizard needed!

Back to EMULATE

From Ed Beroset · 1996-04-09 13:49 · #73674 in EMULATE

In reply to Re: Help! Wizard needed! by Chris Downs

In a msg on <Apr 09 07:49>, to Ed Beroset, Chris Downs writes:

 EB>>> I don't know the kinds of projects on which you 
 EB>>> typically work, but the generalization "clock ticks 
 EB>>> don't matter very often" isn't accurate in my world.  
 CD>  
 EB>> Some of us work with interrupt driven embedded systems 
 EB>> projects which have such tight time and code space budgets 
 EB>> that even using C at all is in question (vs. assembly 
 EB>> language).  Chris' statements may be true *in his domain*, 
 EB>> but they're certainly not universally true.

 CD>  Clock ticks don't matter very often still rings true to me.  

I certainly didn't imagine you'd change your mind.  The message was an apparently failed attempt at gaining mutual understanding.

 CD> But you seem  to be admitting above that it's YOUR domain that's 
 CD> exceptional.  

Yes, I should think that's fairly obvious.  

 CD> And  please Ed, don't mischaracterize my views.  Turning "don't matter 
 CD> very  often" into "universally true" isn't anything close to accurate.  

Let's try the schematic form:

Observer 1 makes statement A:  "It not cold here very often."  
Observer 2 makes statement B:  "Statement A is not universally true."

Observer 1, whose observations led him or her to believe statement A, might wonder why so many others seem to be obsessed with staying warm.  He states that such a preoccupation is, in his opinion, misguided.

Observer 2, who lives at a polar research station might try to explain to the first observer that there are other locations for which the generalization is not true, and that this "obsession" might make a whole lot of sense in some other contexts.  

Some possible conclusions are:

1.  Observer 1 is wrong and deserves the scorn of observer 2.
2.  Observer 2 is wrong but wishes to defame observer 1.
3.  Both observers are wrong and should be either ignored or flamed.
4.  Both are correct; the combination of their statements yields a more complete picture. 

 CD> If  I'm doing a miserable interpretation of your comment, then I 
 CD> apologize.  Otherwise here's a thanks in advance for your consideration in 
 CD> the  future.

I'll let you decide which is appropriate.

 EB>> I was trying to explain why what he might construe as "an obsession with 
 EB>> clock ticks" is, in other areas, simply sound engineering practice.
 CD>  
 CD>  Yes there are plenty of exceptions to the "not very often" criteria.  

I believe I've read that somewhere.  I wonder if it's true?

-> Ed <-

--- Squish v1.01
 * Origin: = Psychotronic BBS // 919-286-4542 // Durham, NC = (1:3641/1.250)