From Jerry Coffin · 1996-04-06 18:14 · #73563 in EMULATE
On (05 Apr 96) Ed Beroset wrote to Jerry Coffin...
EB> FWIW, my recollection is that it was patented by Microsoft, not IBM,
EB> and was from an earlier version of OS/2 (1.2?) before Microsoft and
EB> IBM parted ways. If I am not mistaken, Andrew Schulman's
EB> _Undocumented_Windows95_ refers to this. Maybe somebody with a handy
EB> copy could look it up.
That's what I was going by (though the name is _Unauthorized_Windows_95_
rather than "Undocumented".) I quote:
Now don't all you OS/2 fans out there start snickering about how
ridiculous Windows is because it's built using illegal instructions.
OS/2 2.x uses the same scheme, and you can look it up.
Earlier in the writeup he notes that
Microsoft's use of an illegal instruction to make the hyperspace
jump from 16 bit real mode to 32 bit protected mode is remarkably
similar to a well-known technique dating back over twenty years to
IBM's BM operating system, which used an illegal instruction as a
supervisor call.
However, you're correct that despite this fact that it IS MS who
obtained a patent on the technique.
From the dates, it appears likely to me that this work was done by MS
on OS/2 2.0 before IBM and MS parted ways - the patent was issued in
1990, so it was likely applied for in 1987 or so (unfortunately I don't
have a copy of the patent to check for the application date. ) Given the
time-frame, OS/2 2.0 seems the most likely possibility, but it might
barely come from early work on Windows 3.0 or Windows/386 2.x.
Unfortunately, documentation on Windows/386 2.x is _extremely_ minimal,
so it's hard to guess whether it used the technique or not.
Later,
Jerry.
... The Universe is a figment of its own imagination.
--- PPoint 1.90
* Origin: Point Pointedly Pointless (1:128/77.3)