Slimelite BBS

Re: ALL THIS AND ANTHOLOG

Back to MARKET

From Clark Ray · 1996-04-08 20:11 · #73408 in MARKET

I can always hear them talk:
Quoting William Wright to Frank Swarbrick:

 FS>Personally, I think that _Rubber Soul_, _Revolver_ and _Abbey
 FS>Road_
 FS>were *all* better than _Sgt. Pepper..._...

 WW> tell me... I only have Sgt. Pepper's. I don't plan on spending _too_
 WW> much money on Beatles albums, as I have more progressive albums still
 WW> to get. but I'd like to know. should I buy the second anthology in
 WW> place of Revolver and Rubber Soul, or get the two original albums?
 WW> should I do the same for A3 in the place of MMT, Abby Road, and Let It
 WW> Be?

No, the Anthology is good, but it should not be a replacement for the
original albums.  Besides, most of the thrill out of the Anthology is
getting to hear different versions and rehearsals for the songs that
finally ended up on the released albums (I actually prefer some of the
Anthology 2 versions over the ones that got released -- for example,
"Good Morning, Good Morning"). If you don't already know the final song,
then I'd assume the Anthology would seem like a waste of time to you.

Get _Revolver_ and get _Magical Mystery Tour_ (this one will satisfy
some Prog beasties in you).  If you really love these, then get the
second Anthology.

Clark Ray
___ Blue Wave/QWK v2.12

--- WILDMAIL!/WC v4.12 
 * Origin: Tulare Co Office of Educ, Visalia, CA  (1:214/33.0)