From Tony Rigby · 1996-04-06 17:15 · #73385 in MARKET
Well, I got this thing at last, and the first thing to say is that it isn't what I was hoping for. That Autumn 1970 concert that I keep going on about is not here. So what DO we get? We get one studio session by the original group, two by the line-up that made "Second Album", where Ian Eyre had replaced Rob Martin on bass, and a concert set from a 1976 line-up consisting of Sonja Kristina, Darryl Way, Mick Jaques (guitar), Tony Reeves (bass) and Stewart Copeland (drums). Right. Let's get the boring stuff out of the way. The BBC always has had a tradition of excellent sound engineering, and by the middle 1970s it was beginning to deploy this in rock music. The 1976 concert is beautifully recorded. That's it. The problem, as usual with post-"Phantasmgoria" Curved Airs, is the material. It's not as bad as "Lovechild", but it's not good. "Woman On A One Night Stand" is a cabaret song, pure and simple - and not in the same league as Slapp Happy's cabaret songs either. And "Hot 'N' Bothered"? What a title! Don't you just love that "'N'"? Isn't it just... rock'n'roll? The other stuff is fairly standard for its period and everybody plays well. This sort of thing is why we had the Sex Pistols. What is pretty clear is that there were three people who counted in CA, and you really need to have all three of them there to make it work. Sonja K, Francis Monkman and Darryl Way set each other's qualities off superbly: take one factor out - in this case Monkman's acerbity - and the system becomes unbalanced. One begins to realise what a rare and good thing the group was at its height. Before that, though, I want to ask a question or two about the songwriting credits. First, I've always assumed that credits to "Linwood" meant Sonja Kristina. There are two such here: "It Happened Today" and "Young Mother In Style". "Thinking On The Floor" and "Woman On A One Night Stand" are in part credited to "Winwood". Surely not? I think these are misprints for "Linwood". "Woman On A One Night Stand", "Midnight Wire", "Hot 'N' Bothered" and "The Fool" are co-ascribed to "Tager". Who is "Tager"? I don't know. OK. Now the good stuff. We start with three songs from a studio session from April 1970, probably for John Peel. "Vivaldi" is first, as I suppose it might be. A rather tentative version, this, it being so early in the piece's career. It includes a violin theme that's mind-wrenchingly familiar and which I just can't place, although something keeps saying Debussy or Ravel to me. Possibly it's something the former used in "Children's Corner". Incidentally, does any of you north Americans know the significance of the hornpipe in the "Curved Air Live" version of "Vivaldi"? Whatever, "Propositions" and "It Happened Today" follow: satisfactory performances of both. "It Happened Today" was the song that always used to open their live shows, BTW. Moving from mono into stereo, the next two sets are both from January 1971, with Ian Eyre having replaced Rob Martin on bass. "Young Mother In Style" is of course "Young Mother" that leads off "Second Album". Instrumentally it appears pretty well realised, but the rather unsatisfactory lyric was thoroughly rewritten for the album. Interesting. Eminently satisfactory recordings of "Situations", "Blind Man" and "Thinking On The Floor" follow, and then we get "Stretch". A lot of groups did this sort of thing if they could. I mean of course the idea that goes something like "The Jefferson Airplane have got a girl singer: so have we. Let's go!" Fairport Convention for one did it, most obviously on "Come All Ye" from "Liege And Lief". As far as CA are concerned the Airplane's connection with Papa John Creach can only have encouraged them. Whatever, "Stretch" here appears in all its heads down glory. On stage they used it mostly as an encore, where it was really at home. Not quite mosh pit mayhem, but close. So that's it. Some interesting and some excellent moments from the life of one of the best - if not the best - progressive groups of the early 1970s, and a concert from when they were neither progressive nor best. Worth having? Yes, for sure. Anything that has Sonja K, Darryl Way and Francis Monkman together is worth having, and Way plays well even in the tedious 1976 concert - the instrumental "Stark Naked" is just about OK. Compare it, though, with "It Happened Today", where Monkman switches frantically from guitar to keyboard and back. Well, he used to on stage anyhow: I suppose they might have overdubbed it in the studio session. He wasn't so much playing guitar, either. It was a wah-wah pedal he was playing. And the introduction to "Young Mother" where he uses his synthesiser to imitate Way's violin style. Cunning, huh? Vote Labour. You know it makes sense. Bye... T. --- Terminate 3.00/Pro * Origin: One of Susy's better points (2:254/288.4)