Slimelite BBS

RE: ?'s on progrock

Back to MARKET

From Mike Taylor · 1996-04-06 21:48 · #73347 in MARKET

Thus quoth the Raven ...

 JT> Would someone give me an idea on what progressive rock is. 
 JT> I enjoy Rush and especially Pink Floyd.

Both bands are topical.  Here's the standard canned answer for defining Prog for this echo:

As moderator of this echo, I am often asked to define Progressive Rock.  As a whole, this is futile because everyone has a different vision of "progressive." However, I will try to make clear what it means for this echo:

The biggest problem stems from the literal defintion of progressive.  Progress means improvement or moving forward.  By using this definition, progressive music will never sound the same as it will always be moving forward into new and unexplored areas.  For example, if a band's first album is a radical and new direction in music, it may be called progressive.  If the second album is exactly the same style as the first, no progress has been made so it is *not* a progressive album.  Yet, it may still be considered a progressive album because the *style* on the first album was progressive.  Remember this point while we jump back in time to 1969.

All through the late '60s, the rock bands were enjoying incredible experimental freedom in the studio and the Psychedelic era was flourishing. Bands were moving beyond the 3-4 minute song into long psychedelic explorations that often lasted an entire LP side.  At the same time, other bands, such as the Nice, were using Classical motifs set in a Rock foundation. Classical structures provided a complexity of time and key that was previously little used in Rock music.  Looking back, it seems natural that the structure of Classical music would mate with the psychedelic explorations.  Progressive Rock was born.

Of course, these bands didn't say, "Hey, we just created Progressive Rock!" It was simply a natural result of studio experimentation and freedom, and the public was eating it up.  It was the media and record moguls who first used the term progressive to explain the new style of Rock.  Compared to the Psychedelic Rock of 1966-1968, this new style was indeed progress.  However, progressive was an unfortunate term.  Countless bands released music during that era, most of it very similar in style to each other.  There were bands influenced by Yes, bands influenced by Genesis, and bands influenced by King Crimson, though none of them truly broke new territory.  Yet, they were still called progressive bands.  Why?  Recall the point I made above.  All these bands played in a *style* that had been termed progressive.  It is at this juncture that we are no longer talking about the literal definition of progress.  Instead, we are talking about a genre, that known as Progressive Rock.  Note that I've use capitalization to designate the genre, while a lower case "p" indicates the definitive use of the word progressive.  The misnomer of the genre, I believe, is the main source of misunderstanding as people try to categorize bands as Progressive (progressive?) or not.

Now is a good time to define the style of Progressive Rock.  I can hear an album and decide for myself if it is Progressive.  But I lack the verbal skills to translate what I hear into words.  However, a friend, Mike Feathers, once wrote a very apt definition of the genre.  By far, this is one of the most successful attempts at defining the style as I have seen:

"Progressive seems to be more like the mixture of a style and an attitude. The style may have the following elements (but doesn't need all of them to qualify): shifting meters and keys, episodic sectional compositions, heavy reliance on harmony from western classical music, early psych, or jazz fusion. All of this is usually approached from the rock perspective using the dynamics and aggressive approach of that form of music.  The attitude is one of exploration and ruthless exploitation of complexity in all its forms: rhythmic, melodic, harmonic, and architectural.  Again, not all these elements may be present at once, but they often are.  The last thing I'll mention about attitude is that progressive musicians generally have no problem adopting the stylings of classical music if they are the most appropriate ones for conveying a particular mood or texture."

What you must now realize is that this echo is for the discussion of Progressive Rock, the genre.  There are countless bands that may be progressive (moving forward) and that is a good thing.  But progressive rock is not what this echo is about; Progressive Rock is the sole reason for this echo.

There is one caveat: You will also see occasional pure jazz and classical discussion on occasion.  This is because 1) we (me and the original moderators) didn't like the slant of the Fidonet JAZZ echo and 2) there is no place to discuss Classical music.  As many Progressive fans are also fans of Jazz and Classical, we expanded the boundaries of this echo. This does not make this echo a free-for-all for any band from the '60s or '70s though it may seem that way.  Thus, if you are unsure of an artist's suitability for this echo, I suggest that you ask me first. Please bear in mind that if I rule against your favorite band, I am not saying the band is bad or you have poor tastes.  This echo is very specialized and I am merely saying, using the guidelines above, your band does not fit within its scope.

I should make mention of one other potentially confusing fact:  The official Fidonet tag name for this echo is 60S_70S_PROGROCK, to signify discussion of a core discussion of Progressive Rock from the late '60s and through the mid '70s.  Some sysops, however, may name the echo something else entirely, such as '60s & '70s Rock.  This gives users of that system the impression that this echo is for discussion of *all* Rock music from that era.  As I hope I have made clear, that is not the case.  If you are a user of such a system, I would appreciate it if you would pass this message along to the sysop and ask him or her to change the name to Progressive Rock or other suitable title.

I hope this messages has made some (ahem!) progress toward your complete understanding of the scope and purpose of this echo.  Please don't hesitate to ask if you have other questions.


Mike Taylor, 1:396/11.6
Moderator, 60S_70S_PROGROCK

--- Obolus 1.0.2
 * Origin: Sink beneath the waters to the coral sand below (1:396/11.6)