From Michael Chamberlain · 1996-04-03 00:38 · #73172 in FREE25
In reply to An political question by Louie Gonsalves
In a message of 28 Mar 96 HECTOR SANTOS wrote to LAURENCE LANE: HS> Hello Laurence! HS> In a message to Mark Lewis <03/26/96> Laurence Lane wrote: HS> You see Laurence, you must of did a REPLY TO THE OTHER GUY and wrote HS> the message to Mark Lewis. This is cool, but the REPLY address is wrong. HS> It is WRONG because anyone that wishes to contact Mark Lewis via HS> netmail using your message that you wrote to MARK LEWIS, will get send HS> to MY ADDRESS. And? Please point out to me (and everybody else) where FTS-9 says the address in the REPLY kludge is to be the address of the recipient of the message. I think you'll find this difficult, primarily because it doesn't say so. It says that the address is a verbatim copy of the address in the MSGID to which this message is a reply. It doesn't say that the address in the REPLY has anything to do with the sender or recipient of the message, or that the address has anything at all to do with the message, other than being a verbatim copy of the address in the MSGID in the message to which this is a reply. HS> Call it what you want. The difference is HOW you recreate the the HS> proper MESSAGE IDENTIFICATION for the next message. I understand you HS> have a hard time seeing the picture, not being a software author. The simple answer- you don't. The REPLY kludge does not contain this functionality. The fact that it may be impossible to determine the address, however, does not give you the right to redefine what is supposed to be in the REPLY kludge. To draw an analogy, many programs used the MSGID address as a FTN format address when trying to create a reply, as in some cases it was the only way to do so. However, the FTS-9 spec does not say that the MSGID address is FTN format. It does say that it is an address valid in the originating network. Therefore, by your logic, it is valid for these programs to assume that the address is FTN format as this improves addressing. Do you agree with this? If not, the logic for using the REPLY kludge as you do is broken, and therefore so is your software. I'm sure you'll say that this analogy is invalid. When you do, please explain explicitly why it is invalid, so that I can understand your point, instead of just saying it is invalid with no reason why. Mike. --- Spot 1.3a #355 * Origin: The Point of it all (3:633/265.9)